"People are wrong when they say opera is not what it used to be. It is what it used to be. That is what's wrong with it"
About this Quote
Coward skewers opera with the elegance of someone who knows exactly how tradition can curdle into complacency. The line works because it flips a familiar lament on its head: instead of mourning decline, he suggests the real crisis is stasis. Opera hasn’t degraded; it has fossilized. The punch is in the deadpan logic of it - “It is what it used to be” - a sentence that sounds like praise until the trapdoor opens on “That is what’s wrong with it.”
The intent isn’t simply to dunk on a genre. Coward is diagnosing an arts culture that confuses reverence with vitality. Opera, in his framing, is trapped by its own museum glass: canonical works, ritualized performance styles, a social aura that can feel like inherited etiquette. By the mid-20th century, when Coward’s sensibility was ascendant, modernism and popular entertainment were pressuring “high” forms to justify themselves as living art rather than prestige artifacts. Coward, a playwright who thrived on speed, wit, and contemporary manners, has little patience for a stage language that insists on behaving as if the world hasn’t changed.
The subtext is also a jab at audiences. If opera remains “what it used to be,” it’s partly because patrons want it that way: a dependable pageant of cultural capital. Coward’s cynicism lands because it targets the comfort of repetition, the way institutions protect their glory by embalming it, then calling the result timeless.
The intent isn’t simply to dunk on a genre. Coward is diagnosing an arts culture that confuses reverence with vitality. Opera, in his framing, is trapped by its own museum glass: canonical works, ritualized performance styles, a social aura that can feel like inherited etiquette. By the mid-20th century, when Coward’s sensibility was ascendant, modernism and popular entertainment were pressuring “high” forms to justify themselves as living art rather than prestige artifacts. Coward, a playwright who thrived on speed, wit, and contemporary manners, has little patience for a stage language that insists on behaving as if the world hasn’t changed.
The subtext is also a jab at audiences. If opera remains “what it used to be,” it’s partly because patrons want it that way: a dependable pageant of cultural capital. Coward’s cynicism lands because it targets the comfort of repetition, the way institutions protect their glory by embalming it, then calling the result timeless.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|---|
| Source | Unverified source: Design for Living (Noel Coward, 1933)
Evidence: Act III, Scene I (page number varies by edition). This line is spoken by the character Gilda in Coward’s play. Multiple secondary references consistently locate it in Act III, Scene I, and some sources explicitly attribute it to Gilda. However, I did not find a freely accessible scan of the 1933 ... Other candidates (2) The Mammoth Book of Great British Humour (Michael Powell, 2010) compilation95.9% ... People are wrong when they say opera is not what it used to be . It is what it used to be . That is what's wrong ... C. A. Lejeune (Noel Coward) compilation35.7% onable to assumethat they are going to do their job properly for mr astaire in the next edition to be published for m... |
More Quotes by Noel
Add to List
