"People who commit crimes should be responsible for those crimes. It doesn't matter whether they're priests or ministers or atheists"
About this Quote
Law-and-order rhetoric loves a simple moral syllogism, and Ashcroft delivers it with prosecutorly bluntness: crime is crime, status is irrelevant. On the surface, it reads like basic fairness. The real work happens in the casting call he chooses. “Priests or ministers or atheists” is a deliberately loaded triad, designed to preempt the two most common escapes from public accountability: religious authority as shield, and ideological identity as distraction.
The line carries the DNA of the early-2000s culture fights, when scandals involving clergy were colliding with a rising “values” political brand. Ashcroft, a conservative Christian and then the nation’s top law enforcement official, is speaking into a moment when critics suspected that certain institutions or constituencies might get kid-glove treatment. By naming clergy first, he signals independence from his own perceived base; by adding “atheists,” he widens the frame to include people often treated as cultural outsiders, reassuring them the standard won’t tilt against them either. It’s less about empathy than credibility.
Subtext: the Justice Department is the adult in the room, unimpressed by moral posturing. The sentence doesn’t argue for a policy; it performs impartiality. That performance matters because Ashcroft’s tenure was defined by power claims after 9/11. In that light, the quote doubles as a boundary marker: whatever expansive tools the state uses, individual culpability remains the story we’re supposed to focus on. It’s a clean principle, and also a strategic one.
The line carries the DNA of the early-2000s culture fights, when scandals involving clergy were colliding with a rising “values” political brand. Ashcroft, a conservative Christian and then the nation’s top law enforcement official, is speaking into a moment when critics suspected that certain institutions or constituencies might get kid-glove treatment. By naming clergy first, he signals independence from his own perceived base; by adding “atheists,” he widens the frame to include people often treated as cultural outsiders, reassuring them the standard won’t tilt against them either. It’s less about empathy than credibility.
Subtext: the Justice Department is the adult in the room, unimpressed by moral posturing. The sentence doesn’t argue for a policy; it performs impartiality. That performance matters because Ashcroft’s tenure was defined by power claims after 9/11. In that light, the quote doubles as a boundary marker: whatever expansive tools the state uses, individual culpability remains the story we’re supposed to focus on. It’s a clean principle, and also a strategic one.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List






