"Perception is a clash of mind and eye, the eye believing what it sees, the mind seeing what it believes"
About this Quote
Perception, Brault suggests, isn’t a neutral recording device; it’s a contact sport. By staging it as a “clash of mind and eye,” he rejects the comforting idea that seeing is simply believing. The eye, in his framing, is credulous in a blunt, mechanical way: it “believ[es] what it sees,” taking the world at face value, mistaking immediacy for truth. The mind is just as stubborn, but sneakier: it “see[s] what it believes,” laundering prior commitments into apparent observation.
The line works because it’s built on a mirrored structure that feels self-evident even as it destabilizes you. Those two clauses are almost identical, yet they accuse different parts of us of different kinds of gullibility. The subtext is that objectivity is less a destination than a negotiated ceasefire. If your politics, fears, or desires are strong enough, the mind doesn’t merely interpret the evidence; it manufactures the evidence it needs. Meanwhile, the eye’s confidence can become its own trap: optical illusions, staged images, curated feeds.
Contextually, Brault lands in a late-20th-century commonsense skepticism shaped by cognitive psychology and media saturation: confirmation bias, motivated reasoning, “seeing is believing” flipped into “believing is seeing.” He’s not doing academic epistemology so much as offering a portable diagnostic for everyday life. The intent isn’t to make you distrust your senses; it’s to make you suspicious of the seamless story you tell yourself about why you’re so sure.
The line works because it’s built on a mirrored structure that feels self-evident even as it destabilizes you. Those two clauses are almost identical, yet they accuse different parts of us of different kinds of gullibility. The subtext is that objectivity is less a destination than a negotiated ceasefire. If your politics, fears, or desires are strong enough, the mind doesn’t merely interpret the evidence; it manufactures the evidence it needs. Meanwhile, the eye’s confidence can become its own trap: optical illusions, staged images, curated feeds.
Contextually, Brault lands in a late-20th-century commonsense skepticism shaped by cognitive psychology and media saturation: confirmation bias, motivated reasoning, “seeing is believing” flipped into “believing is seeing.” He’s not doing academic epistemology so much as offering a portable diagnostic for everyday life. The intent isn’t to make you distrust your senses; it’s to make you suspicious of the seamless story you tell yourself about why you’re so sure.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List




