Skip to main content

Aging & Wisdom Quote by Olive Schreiner

"Perhaps the old monks were right when they tried to root love out; perhaps the poets are right when they try to water it. It is a blood-red flower, with the color of sin; but there is always the scent of a god about it"

About this Quote

Schreiner stages love as a contested civic project: something institutions either extirpate or cultivate, depending on what kind of society they’re trying to build. The monks and the poets aren’t just literary props; they represent rival regimes of meaning. Monastic discipline treats love as a destabilizing force, a leak in the wall between the self and the world. Poetry treats it as a necessary disorder, the one chaos worth tending. By granting both sides a tentative “perhaps,” Schreiner refuses easy moral sorting. She’s not picking a camp so much as exposing the price each camp pays.

The “blood-red flower” is doing double duty. It’s lush, alive, and unmistakably bodily; it’s also stained with transgression, “the color of sin,” which collapses Victorian sexual panic into a single visual. Schreiner’s brilliance is that she doesn’t sanitize the erotic to make it respectable. She keeps the red. The move that flips the entire passage is the final clause: “always the scent of a god.” Love may look like sin from the outside, but it carries a trace of the sacred that can’t be legislated away. Scent is an inspired choice: intangible, involuntary, impossible to argue with. You can shut your eyes to the flower; you can’t quite stop breathing.

In Schreiner’s late-19th-century context, this is quietly insurgent. A woman writer, skeptical of inherited pieties, reframes desire not as a moral failure but as a mixed element of human life: dangerous, holy-adjacent, and therefore too complex for either ascetic purges or sentimental hymns.

Quote Details

TopicLove
SourceHelp us find the source
CiteCite this Quote

Citation Formats

APA Style (7th ed.)
Schreiner, Olive. (n.d.). Perhaps the old monks were right when they tried to root love out; perhaps the poets are right when they try to water it. It is a blood-red flower, with the color of sin; but there is always the scent of a god about it. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/perhaps-the-old-monks-were-right-when-they-tried-130150/

Chicago Style
Schreiner, Olive. "Perhaps the old monks were right when they tried to root love out; perhaps the poets are right when they try to water it. It is a blood-red flower, with the color of sin; but there is always the scent of a god about it." FixQuotes. Accessed February 3, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/perhaps-the-old-monks-were-right-when-they-tried-130150/.

MLA Style (9th ed.)
"Perhaps the old monks were right when they tried to root love out; perhaps the poets are right when they try to water it. It is a blood-red flower, with the color of sin; but there is always the scent of a god about it." FixQuotes, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/perhaps-the-old-monks-were-right-when-they-tried-130150/. Accessed 3 Feb. 2026.

More Quotes by Olive Add to List
Olive Schreiner on Love as a Blood-Red Flower
Click to enlarge Portrait | Landscape

About the Author

South Africa Flag

Olive Schreiner (March 24, 1855 - December 11, 1920) was a Writer from South Africa.

9 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes

Jiddu Krishnamurti, Philosopher