"Perhaps the old monks were right when they tried to root love out; perhaps the poets are right when they try to water it. It is a blood-red flower, with the color of sin; but there is always the scent of a god about it"
About this Quote
The “blood-red flower” is doing double duty. It’s lush, alive, and unmistakably bodily; it’s also stained with transgression, “the color of sin,” which collapses Victorian sexual panic into a single visual. Schreiner’s brilliance is that she doesn’t sanitize the erotic to make it respectable. She keeps the red. The move that flips the entire passage is the final clause: “always the scent of a god.” Love may look like sin from the outside, but it carries a trace of the sacred that can’t be legislated away. Scent is an inspired choice: intangible, involuntary, impossible to argue with. You can shut your eyes to the flower; you can’t quite stop breathing.
In Schreiner’s late-19th-century context, this is quietly insurgent. A woman writer, skeptical of inherited pieties, reframes desire not as a moral failure but as a mixed element of human life: dangerous, holy-adjacent, and therefore too complex for either ascetic purges or sentimental hymns.
Quote Details
| Topic | Love |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
| Cite | Cite this Quote |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Schreiner, Olive. (n.d.). Perhaps the old monks were right when they tried to root love out; perhaps the poets are right when they try to water it. It is a blood-red flower, with the color of sin; but there is always the scent of a god about it. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/perhaps-the-old-monks-were-right-when-they-tried-130150/
Chicago Style
Schreiner, Olive. "Perhaps the old monks were right when they tried to root love out; perhaps the poets are right when they try to water it. It is a blood-red flower, with the color of sin; but there is always the scent of a god about it." FixQuotes. Accessed February 3, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/perhaps-the-old-monks-were-right-when-they-tried-130150/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"Perhaps the old monks were right when they tried to root love out; perhaps the poets are right when they try to water it. It is a blood-red flower, with the color of sin; but there is always the scent of a god about it." FixQuotes, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/perhaps-the-old-monks-were-right-when-they-tried-130150/. Accessed 3 Feb. 2026.








