"Permanence, perseverance and persistence in spite of all obstacle s, discouragement s, and impossibilities: It is this, that in all things distinguishes the strong soul from the weak"
About this Quote
Carlyle is selling toughness as a moral aesthetic: the “strong soul” earns its rank not by purity of belief or brilliance of mind, but by sheer staying power. The triple drumbeat - “permanence, perseverance and persistence” - isn’t just Victorian alliteration; it’s a worldview that treats history like a forge. Life supplies “obstacles, discouragements, and impossibilities,” and character is measured by who keeps striking the anvil after the metal cools.
The subtext is less inspirational poster, more hierarchy. Carlyle doesn’t frame endurance as one admirable trait among many; he makes it the dividing line between “strong” and “weak,” a moral sorting mechanism that flatters stoicism and quietly shames collapse. “Impossibilities” is the tell: he’s not describing reasonable grit in hard circumstances, he’s sanctifying the will that refuses to accept limits at all. That’s romantic hero-worship in sentence form, a signature Carlylean move.
Context matters. Carlyle wrote in an age drunk on industrial acceleration, social unrest, and the uneasy question of who deserves power when old aristocratic justifications are crumbling. His answer, across essays like “Signs of the Times” and “Heroes and Hero-Worship,” was a kind of spiritual meritocracy: strong individuals should lead because they can bear the strain. The line reads as both pep talk and political theory - the ethic of endurance as a credential for authority, and a warning that surrender is not merely failure but weakness of soul.
The subtext is less inspirational poster, more hierarchy. Carlyle doesn’t frame endurance as one admirable trait among many; he makes it the dividing line between “strong” and “weak,” a moral sorting mechanism that flatters stoicism and quietly shames collapse. “Impossibilities” is the tell: he’s not describing reasonable grit in hard circumstances, he’s sanctifying the will that refuses to accept limits at all. That’s romantic hero-worship in sentence form, a signature Carlylean move.
Context matters. Carlyle wrote in an age drunk on industrial acceleration, social unrest, and the uneasy question of who deserves power when old aristocratic justifications are crumbling. His answer, across essays like “Signs of the Times” and “Heroes and Hero-Worship,” was a kind of spiritual meritocracy: strong individuals should lead because they can bear the strain. The line reads as both pep talk and political theory - the ethic of endurance as a credential for authority, and a warning that surrender is not merely failure but weakness of soul.
Quote Details
| Topic | Perseverance |
|---|
More Quotes by Thomas
Add to List
