"Pessimism is a luxury that a Jew can never allow himself"
About this Quote
Pessimism, in Golda Meir's framing, is not a mood but an indulgence - the kind you can afford only when your survival is not constantly being renegotiated. The line lands with the blunt moral accounting of a leader who came of age with pogroms in living memory and whose adulthood was bracketed by the Holocaust and the wars that followed Israel's founding. For Meir, "luxury" is a deliberately jarring word: it yanks despair out of the realm of private feeling and recasts it as a social cost.
The intent is twofold. Internally, it functions as discipline: a demand that Jews, and especially Israelis, stay oriented toward action even when history supplies endless evidence for dread. Externally, it reads as argument. If pessimism is off-limits, then persistence becomes not just admirable but compulsory, and the political project of security and statehood becomes morally insulated from the charge of naivete. The subtext is hard-edged: hope is not optimism; hope is strategy.
It's also a line with a shadow. Declaring pessimism impermissible can flatten legitimate grief or dissent into weakness, a familiar move in societies organized around emergency. Meir's sentence works because it compresses a century of contingency into one bracing rule of conduct. It offers no comfort, only a posture: keep building, keep defending, keep moving - because the alternative is a privilege history did not grant you.
The intent is twofold. Internally, it functions as discipline: a demand that Jews, and especially Israelis, stay oriented toward action even when history supplies endless evidence for dread. Externally, it reads as argument. If pessimism is off-limits, then persistence becomes not just admirable but compulsory, and the political project of security and statehood becomes morally insulated from the charge of naivete. The subtext is hard-edged: hope is not optimism; hope is strategy.
It's also a line with a shadow. Declaring pessimism impermissible can flatten legitimate grief or dissent into weakness, a familiar move in societies organized around emergency. Meir's sentence works because it compresses a century of contingency into one bracing rule of conduct. It offers no comfort, only a posture: keep building, keep defending, keep moving - because the alternative is a privilege history did not grant you.
Quote Details
| Topic | Resilience |
|---|
More Quotes by Golda
Add to List





