"Pessimism only describes an attitude, and not facts, and hence is entirely subjective"
About this Quote
Pessimism, in Yockey's framing, is a mood masquerading as a worldview - a private weather system mistaken for climate data. The sentence is built like a corrective, even a rebuke: stop treating gloom as evidence. By demoting pessimism to "attitude" and elevating "facts" to a separate category, he’s policing the boundary between feeling and reality, then using that boundary to shame certain interpretations as merely temperamental.
The move is rhetorically slick because it borrows the authority of objectivity without having to prove anything objective. Label your opponent "pessimistic" and you don’t have to engage their arguments; you can diagnose them. The phrase "hence is entirely subjective" works like a trapdoor: once pessimism is declared subjective, it becomes disqualified from serious debate. That’s not neutral philosophy; it’s a strategy for legitimizing a preferred narrative as the only adult, factual one.
Context matters. Yockey was not a detached observer of modernity but an ideological writer in the postwar ruins, committed to grand historical claims and political revivalism. In that setting, pessimism is dangerous because it undermines mobilization. If people believe decline is real, they don’t join projects that promise resurgence. So the line reads less like a meditation on epistemology and more like a piece of morale management: reframe despair as personal weakness, clear the ground for conviction, and let "facts" become whatever the convinced can assert with a straight face.
The move is rhetorically slick because it borrows the authority of objectivity without having to prove anything objective. Label your opponent "pessimistic" and you don’t have to engage their arguments; you can diagnose them. The phrase "hence is entirely subjective" works like a trapdoor: once pessimism is declared subjective, it becomes disqualified from serious debate. That’s not neutral philosophy; it’s a strategy for legitimizing a preferred narrative as the only adult, factual one.
Context matters. Yockey was not a detached observer of modernity but an ideological writer in the postwar ruins, committed to grand historical claims and political revivalism. In that setting, pessimism is dangerous because it undermines mobilization. If people believe decline is real, they don’t join projects that promise resurgence. So the line reads less like a meditation on epistemology and more like a piece of morale management: reframe despair as personal weakness, clear the ground for conviction, and let "facts" become whatever the convinced can assert with a straight face.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|
More Quotes by Francis
Add to List
