"Philosophical theories or ideas, as points of view, instruments of criticism, may help us to gather up what might otherwise pass unregarded by us"
About this Quote
Pater is quietly arguing for theory as a kind of cultivated eyesight, not a cathedral you’re required to worship in. In the late Victorian moment that prized moral certainty and system-building, he offers a more insinuating proposal: philosophical “points of view” are valuable precisely because they are provisional. They are “instruments of criticism,” tools you pick up to notice what daily habit and received opinion make invisible. The force of the line comes from its modesty. Pater doesn’t claim philosophy delivers Truth; he claims it rescues experience from neglect.
The subtext is a defense of the critic’s vocation against two easy accusations: that criticism is parasitic on “real” art, and that theory is an arid game. By framing ideas as lenses, he turns criticism into attentive care. The critic’s job is to “gather up” the overlooked: tonal shifts, minor sensations, half-formed intuitions, the strange residue that doesn’t fit the official story of an artwork or an era. That verb matters. It suggests salvage and curation, the work of assembling value from what’s scattered and easily discarded.
Contextually, this sits inside Aestheticism’s campaign to make perception itself an ethical discipline. Pater’s famous emphasis on intensity and nuance is often caricatured as escapism; here he shows its sterner edge. Theory is not a substitute for life but a practice that keeps life from “passing unregarded,” a warning against the deadening power of familiarity and dogma.
The subtext is a defense of the critic’s vocation against two easy accusations: that criticism is parasitic on “real” art, and that theory is an arid game. By framing ideas as lenses, he turns criticism into attentive care. The critic’s job is to “gather up” the overlooked: tonal shifts, minor sensations, half-formed intuitions, the strange residue that doesn’t fit the official story of an artwork or an era. That verb matters. It suggests salvage and curation, the work of assembling value from what’s scattered and easily discarded.
Contextually, this sits inside Aestheticism’s campaign to make perception itself an ethical discipline. Pater’s famous emphasis on intensity and nuance is often caricatured as escapism; here he shows its sterner edge. Theory is not a substitute for life but a practice that keeps life from “passing unregarded,” a warning against the deadening power of familiarity and dogma.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Walter
Add to List
