"Philosophy, most broadly viewed, is the critical survey of existence from the standpoint of value"
About this Quote
Hook smuggles a provocation into what looks like a neutral definition: philosophy is not a museum tour of ideas, it is an audit. By calling it a "critical survey of existence", he drags the discipline out of scholastic wordplay and into the messy world of lived choices, institutions, and consequences. "Survey" implies breadth and public usefulness; "critical" implies standards, not mere description. This is philosophy as appraisal, not ornament.
The real hinge is "from the standpoint of value". Hook is signaling that you never evaluate life from nowhere. Even the most allegedly objective metaphysics carries hidden commitments about what matters, what counts as evidence, which harms are tolerable, which freedoms are sacred. His phrasing quietly rejects the fantasy of value-free thinking without collapsing into relativism. A "standpoint" is a position you can argue for, revise, defend - not a private mood. That’s the pragmatist in him: values are not airy sentiments but working hypotheses tested against experience and social outcomes.
Context matters. Hook came up through American pragmatism (Dewey) and spent much of his career wrestling with Marxism, democracy, and the moral stakes of political ideology. In the mid-20th century, when totalitarian systems claimed scientific inevitability and some academics retreated into technical puzzles, Hook insists that philosophy’s job is to ask the uncomfortable question: so what, for whom, and at what cost? The line reads like a mission statement for intellectual adulthood - a refusal to let thought off the hook of responsibility.
The real hinge is "from the standpoint of value". Hook is signaling that you never evaluate life from nowhere. Even the most allegedly objective metaphysics carries hidden commitments about what matters, what counts as evidence, which harms are tolerable, which freedoms are sacred. His phrasing quietly rejects the fantasy of value-free thinking without collapsing into relativism. A "standpoint" is a position you can argue for, revise, defend - not a private mood. That’s the pragmatist in him: values are not airy sentiments but working hypotheses tested against experience and social outcomes.
Context matters. Hook came up through American pragmatism (Dewey) and spent much of his career wrestling with Marxism, democracy, and the moral stakes of political ideology. In the mid-20th century, when totalitarian systems claimed scientific inevitability and some academics retreated into technical puzzles, Hook insists that philosophy’s job is to ask the uncomfortable question: so what, for whom, and at what cost? The line reads like a mission statement for intellectual adulthood - a refusal to let thought off the hook of responsibility.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Sidney
Add to List
