"Philosophy should always know that indifference is a militant thing. It batters down the walls of cities and murders the women and children amid the flames and the purloining of altar vessels. When it goes away it leaves smoking ruins, where lie citizens bayonetted through the throat. It is not a children's pastime like mere highway robbery"
About this Quote
Indifference is usually sold as a mild pose: a shrug, a refusal to take sides, a cool intellectual distance. Crane detonates that lie. He treats indifference as an army, not an attitude, and his language makes sure you feel the boots on the ground. “Militant” isn’t metaphorical decoration here; it’s the thesis. If you stop caring, Crane implies, you don’t step outside conflict - you create the conditions in which the worst actors operate unchallenged.
The brutal inventory of atrocities (“murders the women and children,” “altar vessels,” “bayonetted through the throat”) is intentionally excessive, almost reportorial in its specificity. It’s Crane the war correspondent and naturalist writer refusing the comforting abstraction of “violence” or “tragedy.” He itemizes. He names the looting. He drags sacred objects into the mud to show how indifference doesn’t just kill bodies; it desecrates meaning, tradition, and communal bonds. That odd detail about “purloining of altar vessels” also hints at the hypocrisy that follows mass violence: even in the ruins, someone is still taking souvenirs.
The final jab - “not a children’s pastime like mere highway robbery” - is acid. Crane flips moral expectations: petty crime becomes quaint next to the respectability of not caring. Context matters: writing in the late 19th century, steeped in the realities of modern warfare and social cruelty, Crane is indicting a philosophy culture that prides itself on detachment. The subtext is a warning to the comfortable: neutrality isn’t clean. It has a body count.
The brutal inventory of atrocities (“murders the women and children,” “altar vessels,” “bayonetted through the throat”) is intentionally excessive, almost reportorial in its specificity. It’s Crane the war correspondent and naturalist writer refusing the comforting abstraction of “violence” or “tragedy.” He itemizes. He names the looting. He drags sacred objects into the mud to show how indifference doesn’t just kill bodies; it desecrates meaning, tradition, and communal bonds. That odd detail about “purloining of altar vessels” also hints at the hypocrisy that follows mass violence: even in the ruins, someone is still taking souvenirs.
The final jab - “not a children’s pastime like mere highway robbery” - is acid. Crane flips moral expectations: petty crime becomes quaint next to the respectability of not caring. Context matters: writing in the late 19th century, steeped in the realities of modern warfare and social cruelty, Crane is indicting a philosophy culture that prides itself on detachment. The subtext is a warning to the comfortable: neutrality isn’t clean. It has a body count.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Stephen
Add to List





