"Physics is becoming so unbelievably complex that it is taking longer and longer to train a physicist. It is taking so long, in fact, to train a physicist to the place where he understands the nature of physical problems that he is already too old to solve them"
About this Quote
Wigner’s line lands like a joke told in a seminar room: dry, immaculate, and just cruel enough to sting. On the surface it’s a complaint about graduate school bloat. Underneath, it’s a quiet alarm about what happens when a field’s learning curve becomes a wall. Physics, in his telling, has drifted from a craft you could plausibly master in youth into an institution that metabolizes entire decades before you’re allowed to ask your own questions.
The barb is aimed less at individual aging than at the sociology of modern science. “Too old to solve them” encodes two assumptions: first, that creative risk-taking is disproportionately young (a belief physics has long romanticized, from Newton to Einstein); second, that the system increasingly rewards safe competence over original leaps. Wigner isn’t merely nostalgic for an era of lone geniuses. He’s diagnosing the cost of complexity: as theories and toolkits pile up, the entry ticket becomes encyclopedic fluency. That pushes researchers into narrower subfields, longer apprenticeships, and a culture where the most valuable skill can be not insight but navigation.
Context matters. Wigner helped build the mathematical architecture of 20th-century physics and lived through its postwar explosion: quantum mechanics formalized, nuclear physics industrialized, big labs and big funding normalized. His quip reads as both insider’s lament and institutional critique: when a discipline turns into a maze, it risks confusing the ability to survive the maze with the ability to redraw the map.
The barb is aimed less at individual aging than at the sociology of modern science. “Too old to solve them” encodes two assumptions: first, that creative risk-taking is disproportionately young (a belief physics has long romanticized, from Newton to Einstein); second, that the system increasingly rewards safe competence over original leaps. Wigner isn’t merely nostalgic for an era of lone geniuses. He’s diagnosing the cost of complexity: as theories and toolkits pile up, the entry ticket becomes encyclopedic fluency. That pushes researchers into narrower subfields, longer apprenticeships, and a culture where the most valuable skill can be not insight but navigation.
Context matters. Wigner helped build the mathematical architecture of 20th-century physics and lived through its postwar explosion: quantum mechanics formalized, nuclear physics industrialized, big labs and big funding normalized. His quip reads as both insider’s lament and institutional critique: when a discipline turns into a maze, it risks confusing the ability to survive the maze with the ability to redraw the map.
Quote Details
| Topic | Science |
|---|
More Quotes by Eugene
Add to List
