"Poetry lies its way to the truth"
About this Quote
“Poetry lies its way to the truth” is a dare disguised as a definition. Ciardi flips the usual moral hierarchy - truth good, lying bad - and makes poetry’s alleged dishonesty into its method. The line works because it names what art does in plain, almost mischievous terms: it invents, distorts, compresses, and overstates, then somehow lands closer to lived reality than the factual record ever can.
Ciardi’s “lies” aren’t fraud; they’re deliberate contrivances. Metaphor is a lie (“my love is a red, red rose”) that clarifies something unmeasurable. Rhythm and rhyme are lies against ordinary speech that make emotion memorable. Even the lyric “I” is often a mask - a dramatized self. As a dramatist, Ciardi would be attuned to this: characters tell the truth by pretending, and audiences recognize themselves in the performance precisely because it isn’t documentary.
The subtext is also a rebuke to literalism. If you demand that poems behave like affidavits, you miss their job. Poetry deals in the truths that facts can’t secure: grief’s warped sense of time, desire’s self-deception, the private logic of fear. The poem “lies” by building a small artificial world, then tests what it feels like to live inside it.
Context matters: mid-century American letters were wrestling with sincerity versus technique, confession versus craft, propaganda versus imagination. Ciardi’s line stakes out a craft-forward position: not that truth is optional, but that it’s reached sideways - through the honorable trickery of form.
Ciardi’s “lies” aren’t fraud; they’re deliberate contrivances. Metaphor is a lie (“my love is a red, red rose”) that clarifies something unmeasurable. Rhythm and rhyme are lies against ordinary speech that make emotion memorable. Even the lyric “I” is often a mask - a dramatized self. As a dramatist, Ciardi would be attuned to this: characters tell the truth by pretending, and audiences recognize themselves in the performance precisely because it isn’t documentary.
The subtext is also a rebuke to literalism. If you demand that poems behave like affidavits, you miss their job. Poetry deals in the truths that facts can’t secure: grief’s warped sense of time, desire’s self-deception, the private logic of fear. The poem “lies” by building a small artificial world, then tests what it feels like to live inside it.
Context matters: mid-century American letters were wrestling with sincerity versus technique, confession versus craft, propaganda versus imagination. Ciardi’s line stakes out a craft-forward position: not that truth is optional, but that it’s reached sideways - through the honorable trickery of form.
Quote Details
| Topic | Poetry |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by John
Add to List







