"Politics isn't about left versus right; it's about top versus bottom"
About this Quote
Hightower’s line works because it refuses the comforting geometry of ideology. “Left versus right” is the map most people are handed: a neat spectrum where you can sort friends, foes, and Facebook arguments. By swapping in “top versus bottom,” he drags politics out of culture-war abstraction and back into a blunt question of power: who gets to set the rules, who pays, who benefits.
The intent is populist, but not mushy. “Top” and “bottom” aren’t policy positions; they’re social locations. That shift is the point. It suggests that political identity is often a decoy, while the real action happens in boardrooms, regulatory agencies, courts, and donor networks. The subtext is an accusation: elites survive by keeping everyone else busy fighting on the horizontal plane. If you’re arguing left/right, you’re less likely to notice wealth extraction, union-busting, privatization, or the quiet capture of public institutions.
Hightower’s context matters. Coming out of Texas progressive politics and decades of anti-corporate activism, he’s speaking in the tradition of American prairie populism: suspicion of concentrated wealth, impatience with technocratic excuses, and a belief that “the people” are getting played. It’s also a rhetorical move designed to build strange-bedfellow coalitions. If the real divide is vertical, then a minimum-wage worker in a red county and a gig worker in a blue city suddenly have a shared antagonist.
The line is persuasive because it’s a reframe that feels like revelation, then functions like a recruiting slogan: stop picking teams; start tracking power.
The intent is populist, but not mushy. “Top” and “bottom” aren’t policy positions; they’re social locations. That shift is the point. It suggests that political identity is often a decoy, while the real action happens in boardrooms, regulatory agencies, courts, and donor networks. The subtext is an accusation: elites survive by keeping everyone else busy fighting on the horizontal plane. If you’re arguing left/right, you’re less likely to notice wealth extraction, union-busting, privatization, or the quiet capture of public institutions.
Hightower’s context matters. Coming out of Texas progressive politics and decades of anti-corporate activism, he’s speaking in the tradition of American prairie populism: suspicion of concentrated wealth, impatience with technocratic excuses, and a belief that “the people” are getting played. It’s also a rhetorical move designed to build strange-bedfellow coalitions. If the real divide is vertical, then a minimum-wage worker in a red county and a gig worker in a blue city suddenly have a shared antagonist.
The line is persuasive because it’s a reframe that feels like revelation, then functions like a recruiting slogan: stop picking teams; start tracking power.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|---|
| Source | Attributed to Jim Hightower: "Politics isn't about left versus right; it's about top versus bottom." (commonly cited; see Wikiquote entry) |
More Quotes by Jim
Add to List






