"Poor David Hume is dying fast, but with more real cheerfulness and good humor and with more real resignation to the necessary course of things, than any whining Christian ever dyed with pretended resignation to the will of God"
About this Quote
Adam Smith is doing more than praising a friend on his deathbed; he is staging a moral showdown between Enlightenment composure and what he regards as Christian theater. The jab lands with surgical cruelty: “whining” and “pretended” turn piety into performance, while Hume’s “real cheerfulness” becomes an ethical credential. Smith isn’t merely admiring stoicism; he’s indicting a culture that claims serenity through faith yet often polices doubt with melodrama.
The line works because it weaponizes a moment that typically disarms critique. Death is where religious narratives demand the final word. Smith refuses that script, insisting that character can be demonstrated without the theological scaffolding. “Necessary course of things” is the key phrase: it replaces Providence with causality, fate with contingency, God’s plan with the plain fact of mortality. That substitution is the Enlightenment project in miniature, smuggled into what looks like personal testimony.
Context sharpens the provocation. Hume, famously skeptical and widely attacked for it, was an easy target for Christian moralists eager to claim that unbelief must end in terror. Smith counters with an empirical anecdote: look at the evidence, not the doctrine. The comparison is deliberately unfair in the way polemic must be. He stacks the deck by choosing Hume at his best and “any…Christian” at their worst, because the point isn’t statistical accuracy; it’s reputational reversal. If the atheist dies better than the faithful, the culture’s moral hierarchy starts to wobble.
The line works because it weaponizes a moment that typically disarms critique. Death is where religious narratives demand the final word. Smith refuses that script, insisting that character can be demonstrated without the theological scaffolding. “Necessary course of things” is the key phrase: it replaces Providence with causality, fate with contingency, God’s plan with the plain fact of mortality. That substitution is the Enlightenment project in miniature, smuggled into what looks like personal testimony.
Context sharpens the provocation. Hume, famously skeptical and widely attacked for it, was an easy target for Christian moralists eager to claim that unbelief must end in terror. Smith counters with an empirical anecdote: look at the evidence, not the doctrine. The comparison is deliberately unfair in the way polemic must be. He stacks the deck by choosing Hume at his best and “any…Christian” at their worst, because the point isn’t statistical accuracy; it’s reputational reversal. If the atheist dies better than the faithful, the culture’s moral hierarchy starts to wobble.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Adam
Add to List





