"Prayer is a thought, a belief, a feeling, arising within the mind of the one praying"
About this Quote
Holmes drags prayer down from the rafters and pins it to the corkboard of the human psyche. By calling it "a thought, a belief, a feeling", he strips away the usual furniture of prayer - the kneeling, the pleading, the sense of a message hurled upward toward a distant authority. The line is doing quiet but radical work: it relocates the action from God to the person. Prayer, here, isn’t a supernatural transmission. It’s an interior event.
That framing fits Holmes's New Thought context, where mind is not just a private theater but a force with consequences. In that world, prayer is closer to mental practice than religious petition: disciplined attention, emotional alignment, belief held long enough to become real. The phrasing also sidesteps sectarian conflict. No mention of doctrine, church, or even deity. Anyone with a mind can pray, because prayer is defined as something the mind already does.
The subtext is a gentle rebuke to religious outsourcing. If prayer "arises within", then spiritual power isn’t locked behind clergy, ritual correctness, or moral bargaining. It also dodges the hardest theological problem - why prayers go unanswered - by reframing the purpose. Prayer isn’t primarily about changing God’s mind; it’s about changing your own. That’s both empowering and risky. Empowering because it offers agency. Risky because it can slide into self-blame: if outcomes hinge on thought and belief, failure can look like a personal defect. Holmes’s sentence is elegant precisely because it refuses to argue; it simply redefines the terms so the debate can’t proceed on the old terrain.
That framing fits Holmes's New Thought context, where mind is not just a private theater but a force with consequences. In that world, prayer is closer to mental practice than religious petition: disciplined attention, emotional alignment, belief held long enough to become real. The phrasing also sidesteps sectarian conflict. No mention of doctrine, church, or even deity. Anyone with a mind can pray, because prayer is defined as something the mind already does.
The subtext is a gentle rebuke to religious outsourcing. If prayer "arises within", then spiritual power isn’t locked behind clergy, ritual correctness, or moral bargaining. It also dodges the hardest theological problem - why prayers go unanswered - by reframing the purpose. Prayer isn’t primarily about changing God’s mind; it’s about changing your own. That’s both empowering and risky. Empowering because it offers agency. Risky because it can slide into self-blame: if outcomes hinge on thought and belief, failure can look like a personal defect. Holmes’s sentence is elegant precisely because it refuses to argue; it simply redefines the terms so the debate can’t proceed on the old terrain.
Quote Details
| Topic | Prayer |
|---|
More Quotes by Ernest
Add to List




