"Progress everywhere today does seem to come so very heavily disguised as Chaos"
About this Quote
Progress, Grenfell suggests, doesn’t arrive with a ribbon-cutting; it kicks the door in wearing chaos as a costume. Coming from an actress best known for turning social discomfort into art, the line reads like a wry backstage note on modern life: the scene changes are messy, the props fall over, and only later do we call it a “new era.”
The specific intent is both consoling and corrective. Consoling, because it reframes upheaval as a sign that something is moving forward rather than falling apart; corrective, because it punctures our fantasy that improvement should feel orderly, sensible, and politely scheduled. “Heavily disguised” is the key phrase: chaos isn’t just adjacent to progress, it’s progress’s preferred camouflage. You don’t recognize the future while it’s happening because it doesn’t yet have the comforting narrative glue of hindsight.
Subtextually, Grenfell is also taking aim at middle-class craving for stability and legibility. When institutions shift, norms flip, or new voices demand space, the first reaction is often to label the moment “decline,” “breakdown,” “madness.” Her line argues that those labels can be a failure of perception, not evidence. The chaos may be real, even frightening, but it’s also the noise of systems being re-sorted.
Context matters: Grenfell lived through two world wars, rapid social liberalization, and cultural modernization in Britain. For someone steeped in performance, the metaphor lands cleanly: history is a costume drama, and the most radical transformations are the ones that don’t look heroic up close.
The specific intent is both consoling and corrective. Consoling, because it reframes upheaval as a sign that something is moving forward rather than falling apart; corrective, because it punctures our fantasy that improvement should feel orderly, sensible, and politely scheduled. “Heavily disguised” is the key phrase: chaos isn’t just adjacent to progress, it’s progress’s preferred camouflage. You don’t recognize the future while it’s happening because it doesn’t yet have the comforting narrative glue of hindsight.
Subtextually, Grenfell is also taking aim at middle-class craving for stability and legibility. When institutions shift, norms flip, or new voices demand space, the first reaction is often to label the moment “decline,” “breakdown,” “madness.” Her line argues that those labels can be a failure of perception, not evidence. The chaos may be real, even frightening, but it’s also the noise of systems being re-sorted.
Context matters: Grenfell lived through two world wars, rapid social liberalization, and cultural modernization in Britain. For someone steeped in performance, the metaphor lands cleanly: history is a costume drama, and the most radical transformations are the ones that don’t look heroic up close.
Quote Details
| Topic | Embrace Change |
|---|
More Quotes by Joyce
Add to List









