"Projective geometry is all geometry"
About this Quote
A Victorian mathematician drops a line that sounds like a manifesto because, for Cayley, it basically was. “Projective geometry is all geometry” isn’t a smug claim that Euclid is obsolete; it’s a power move about what deserves to count as the real structure of space. Projective geometry keeps the relations that survive when you change perspective: collinearity, incidence, cross-ratios. It deliberately throws away measurements like length and angle, the fussy local details that depend on a ruler, a coordinate choice, or an observer’s position. In a century obsessed with invariants and classification, that’s a philosophical bet: the deepest truths are the ones that don’t blink when you move the camera.
The subtext is unification. Nineteenth-century geometry had splintered into Euclidean, non-Euclidean, affine, and the newly energized projective tradition coming out of Poncelet and von Staudt. Cayley is arguing that projective geometry sits upstream. If you can do geometry in a setting where parallels meet “at infinity” and conics are all variations of one projective object, you can recover the older geometries by adding extra structure back in.
Cayley’s own work makes the slogan concrete. In his “Cayley-Klein” approach, metrics arise from projective data plus an “absolute” conic: distance becomes a derived concept, not a primitive one. The rhetorical trick is bold reduction: call the most general viewpoint “all geometry,” then force every other geometry to justify itself as a specialization. It’s less a definition than a declaration of intellectual jurisdiction.
The subtext is unification. Nineteenth-century geometry had splintered into Euclidean, non-Euclidean, affine, and the newly energized projective tradition coming out of Poncelet and von Staudt. Cayley is arguing that projective geometry sits upstream. If you can do geometry in a setting where parallels meet “at infinity” and conics are all variations of one projective object, you can recover the older geometries by adding extra structure back in.
Cayley’s own work makes the slogan concrete. In his “Cayley-Klein” approach, metrics arise from projective data plus an “absolute” conic: distance becomes a derived concept, not a primitive one. The rhetorical trick is bold reduction: call the most general viewpoint “all geometry,” then force every other geometry to justify itself as a specialization. It’s less a definition than a declaration of intellectual jurisdiction.
Quote Details
| Topic | Knowledge |
|---|
More Quotes by Arthur
Add to List



