"Prosperity cannot be restored by raids upon the public Treasury"
About this Quote
Hoover’s line lands like a gavel: prosperity is not a thing the government can “restore” by rummaging through its own cash drawer. The phrasing matters. “Raids” frames public spending as something closer to looting than policy, a moralized image that turns fiscal stimulus into a breach of trust. And “public Treasury” isn’t just an account; it’s the people’s pooled restraint. Hoover is staking a claim that the state’s first duty in crisis is to protect the commons, not dip into it for quick political relief.
The intent is defensive as much as economic. Hoover is trying to cordon off responsibility: the health of the economy should be rebuilt through production, confidence, and private enterprise, not emergency outlays that risk debt, inflation, or dependency. He’s also speaking to a culture that still treated balanced budgets as civic virtue, not an optional macroeconomic lever.
The subtext is sharper: if hardship is met with “raids,” then voters are being tempted into short-term fixes that weaken the nation’s character and credit. It’s a warning about the politics of generosity, aimed as much at Congress and the press as at rival theories of governance. Coming from a president identified with early Depression orthodoxy, the quote also reads as preemptive self-justification: if recovery doesn’t arrive, at least the Treasury remains un-pillaged. History, of course, would pivot toward the idea that refusing to spend can be its own kind of raid - on livelihoods.
The intent is defensive as much as economic. Hoover is trying to cordon off responsibility: the health of the economy should be rebuilt through production, confidence, and private enterprise, not emergency outlays that risk debt, inflation, or dependency. He’s also speaking to a culture that still treated balanced budgets as civic virtue, not an optional macroeconomic lever.
The subtext is sharper: if hardship is met with “raids,” then voters are being tempted into short-term fixes that weaken the nation’s character and credit. It’s a warning about the politics of generosity, aimed as much at Congress and the press as at rival theories of governance. Coming from a president identified with early Depression orthodoxy, the quote also reads as preemptive self-justification: if recovery doesn’t arrive, at least the Treasury remains un-pillaged. History, of course, would pivot toward the idea that refusing to spend can be its own kind of raid - on livelihoods.
Quote Details
| Topic | Money |
|---|
More Quotes by Herbert
Add to List
