"Prosperity or egalitarianism - you have to choose. I favor freedom - you never achieve real equality anyway: you simply sacrifice prosperity for an illusion"
About this Quote
Vargas Llosa sets the terms like a hard bargain: prosperity or egalitarianism, pick one. It is a deliberately polarizing frame, less a philosophical query than a provocation designed to make the middle ground look naive. The colon does a lot of work here, turning “freedom” into the trump card that supposedly settles the debate. Freedom, in this construction, isn’t just civil liberty; it’s the economic latitude of markets, risk, property, and unequal outcomes. Egalitarianism becomes not a moral aim but a bureaucratic compulsion - something administered, enforced, and therefore hostile to freedom by definition.
The subtext is a scar from Latin America’s 20th-century ideological knife fights. Vargas Llosa watched revolutions promise justice and deliver shortages, censorship, and party-state privilege. So “you never achieve real equality anyway” isn’t merely empirical skepticism; it’s a preemptive strike against the left’s aspirational language. By calling equality an “illusion,” he reframes redistribution as theater: emotionally satisfying, politically useful, materially destructive.
What makes the line rhetorically effective is its asymmetry. Prosperity is measurable; “real equality” is set up as unattainable, a standard no society can meet. That rigging lets him portray any egalitarian policy as failure in advance, while casting prosperity as the only honest metric. Still, the quote’s force comes from what it leaves unsaid: that actual market societies also trade off freedom for order (monopoly, inherited advantage, coercion by necessity) and that egalitarianism isn’t always about perfect sameness, but about reducing domination. The brilliance and the gamble are the same: he turns a messy continuum into a moral fork in the road.
The subtext is a scar from Latin America’s 20th-century ideological knife fights. Vargas Llosa watched revolutions promise justice and deliver shortages, censorship, and party-state privilege. So “you never achieve real equality anyway” isn’t merely empirical skepticism; it’s a preemptive strike against the left’s aspirational language. By calling equality an “illusion,” he reframes redistribution as theater: emotionally satisfying, politically useful, materially destructive.
What makes the line rhetorically effective is its asymmetry. Prosperity is measurable; “real equality” is set up as unattainable, a standard no society can meet. That rigging lets him portray any egalitarian policy as failure in advance, while casting prosperity as the only honest metric. Still, the quote’s force comes from what it leaves unsaid: that actual market societies also trade off freedom for order (monopoly, inherited advantage, coercion by necessity) and that egalitarianism isn’t always about perfect sameness, but about reducing domination. The brilliance and the gamble are the same: he turns a messy continuum into a moral fork in the road.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Mario
Add to List
