"Real answers need to be found in dialogue and interaction and, yes, our shared human condition. This means being open to one another instead of simply fighting to maintain a prescribed position"
About this Quote
Boyd is smuggling a quiet rebuke into pastoral language: certainty, he suggests, is often just ego in clerical robes. The line stages a collision between two ways of living in public. One is positional politics and positional piety, where the goal is to defend a “prescribed position” as if moral life were a debate tournament. The other is relational truth, where “real answers” are not extracted like data but discovered in the friction of encounter.
The key move is his use of “dialogue and interaction” as moral technology. He’s not romanticizing conversation; he’s insisting that wisdom has a social setting. “Real answers” implies counterfeit ones: doctrines repeated without risk, opinions hardened into identity, slogans that relieve us of the burden of seeing the person across from us. When he invokes “our shared human condition,” Boyd isn’t reaching for a bland kumbaya universalism. He’s calling attention to the one fact no ideology can fully edit out: vulnerability. Bodies age, people grieve, everyone needs mercy at some point. Dialogue becomes the place where that truth can interrupt our performative certainty.
Context matters. Boyd, an Episcopal priest who wrote and spoke through the mid-century churn of civil rights, Vietnam, and the reformation of American religious life, represents a strain of postwar Christian humanism wary of authoritarian “answers.” His intent is pastoral but also political: to shift ethics from winning to listening, from maintaining boundaries to testing whether our convictions can survive contact with actual lives. “Open to one another” is the real demand here: not agreement, but exposure.
The key move is his use of “dialogue and interaction” as moral technology. He’s not romanticizing conversation; he’s insisting that wisdom has a social setting. “Real answers” implies counterfeit ones: doctrines repeated without risk, opinions hardened into identity, slogans that relieve us of the burden of seeing the person across from us. When he invokes “our shared human condition,” Boyd isn’t reaching for a bland kumbaya universalism. He’s calling attention to the one fact no ideology can fully edit out: vulnerability. Bodies age, people grieve, everyone needs mercy at some point. Dialogue becomes the place where that truth can interrupt our performative certainty.
Context matters. Boyd, an Episcopal priest who wrote and spoke through the mid-century churn of civil rights, Vietnam, and the reformation of American religious life, represents a strain of postwar Christian humanism wary of authoritarian “answers.” His intent is pastoral but also political: to shift ethics from winning to listening, from maintaining boundaries to testing whether our convictions can survive contact with actual lives. “Open to one another” is the real demand here: not agreement, but exposure.
Quote Details
| Topic | Respect |
|---|
More Quotes by Malcolm
Add to List











