"Recognition of function always precedes recognition of being"
About this Quote
“Recognition of function always precedes recognition of being” is a small, scalpel-sharp diagnosis of how societies decide who counts. Brown, a writer shaped by feminist and queer movements that spent decades arguing for basic legibility, is pointing to a pattern: we tend to grant personhood only after someone proves usefulness. It’s not a metaphysical claim so much as an indictment of social bookkeeping.
The line works because it flips the order we like to imagine. In polite theory, “being” is innate; rights are not earned. In practice, people are asked to audition for dignity. The disabled are pressed to demonstrate productivity. Immigrants are framed as “essential” when they fill labor gaps and “illegal” when they don’t. Women’s autonomy gets rhetorically tethered to motherhood, caretaking, or market value. Even queerness, in its most palatable public forms, is often sold as decorative (culture-making) or stabilizing (good consumers, good neighbors) before it’s simply allowed to exist without explanation.
Brown’s verb choice matters: “recognition” isn’t existence; it’s permission. The quote implies that power doesn’t deny reality, it denies acknowledgment until a function can be extracted. That’s why the sentence lands with a faintly Marxist chill without sounding like a manifesto: it’s one clean observation about how institutions translate humans into roles.
The subtext is a warning and a tactic. If your claim to “being” depends on your “function,” you’re always one economic downturn, political backlash, or personal crisis away from erasure. Brown is asking readers to notice that bargain - and refuse it.
The line works because it flips the order we like to imagine. In polite theory, “being” is innate; rights are not earned. In practice, people are asked to audition for dignity. The disabled are pressed to demonstrate productivity. Immigrants are framed as “essential” when they fill labor gaps and “illegal” when they don’t. Women’s autonomy gets rhetorically tethered to motherhood, caretaking, or market value. Even queerness, in its most palatable public forms, is often sold as decorative (culture-making) or stabilizing (good consumers, good neighbors) before it’s simply allowed to exist without explanation.
Brown’s verb choice matters: “recognition” isn’t existence; it’s permission. The quote implies that power doesn’t deny reality, it denies acknowledgment until a function can be extracted. That’s why the sentence lands with a faintly Marxist chill without sounding like a manifesto: it’s one clean observation about how institutions translate humans into roles.
The subtext is a warning and a tactic. If your claim to “being” depends on your “function,” you’re always one economic downturn, political backlash, or personal crisis away from erasure. Brown is asking readers to notice that bargain - and refuse it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Rita
Add to List






