"Respecting other people's cultures is well and good, but I draw the line at where some branches of Islam, what they do to women. It's indefensible"
About this Quote
Biafra’s line lands like a punk sneer aimed at two targets at once: the easy liberal reflex to applaud “cultural respect,” and the equally easy right-wing habit of using women’s rights as a cudgel to bash Muslims. The phrasing matters. “Well and good” sounds like a shrug at polite multicultural etiquette; “I draw the line” is the old hardcore move of staking a boundary and daring you to argue. He’s not rejecting cultural relativism because he’s suddenly nostalgic for empire. He’s rejecting it because, in his moral universe, there are non-negotiables, and gendered coercion is one of them.
The subtext is the friction between tolerance as a social posture and solidarity as a political ethic. “Some branches of Islam” is a careful hedge, but it also reveals the tightrope: condemn practices without indicting a billion people. That caveat reads less like academic nuance than like a performer’s instinct to keep the critique aimed at institutions and power, not at ordinary believers. Still, the sentence carries the risk it’s trying to dodge: once you invoke “Islam” and “women” in the same breath, you’re stepping into a culture-war script that’s been used to justify surveillance, invasion, and domestic bigotry.
Contextually, Biafra comes from a scene that mistrusts official narratives but also mistrusts feel-good consensus. Punk’s longstanding fixation on hypocrisy makes “It’s indefensible” the key beat: not an invitation to debate, but a refusal to let oppression hide behind the polite fiction that all “cultures” deserve equal deference, regardless of who pays the price.
The subtext is the friction between tolerance as a social posture and solidarity as a political ethic. “Some branches of Islam” is a careful hedge, but it also reveals the tightrope: condemn practices without indicting a billion people. That caveat reads less like academic nuance than like a performer’s instinct to keep the critique aimed at institutions and power, not at ordinary believers. Still, the sentence carries the risk it’s trying to dodge: once you invoke “Islam” and “women” in the same breath, you’re stepping into a culture-war script that’s been used to justify surveillance, invasion, and domestic bigotry.
Contextually, Biafra comes from a scene that mistrusts official narratives but also mistrusts feel-good consensus. Punk’s longstanding fixation on hypocrisy makes “It’s indefensible” the key beat: not an invitation to debate, but a refusal to let oppression hide behind the polite fiction that all “cultures” deserve equal deference, regardless of who pays the price.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Jello
Add to List




