"Responsibility and respect of others and their religious beliefs are also part of freedom"
About this Quote
Freedom sounds clean until it collides with other people. Horst Koehler’s line tries to keep “freedom” from becoming a permission slip for social wreckage, especially in the religious minefields of modern Europe. The sentence is structured like a corrective: yes, you’re free, but the price of that freedom is adulthood - responsibility - and the practical discipline of respecting what others hold sacred.
The intent is defensive as much as aspirational. As a German statesman speaking in a post-9/11, post-cartoon-controversy climate, Koehler is implicitly addressing the recurring question: does free expression include the right to offend? He doesn’t deny the right, but he shifts the frame from legal entitlement to civic consequence. That’s the subtext: a society can protect speech and still expect citizens not to treat provocation as a virtue.
It also quietly redefines freedom as relational rather than purely individual. Respect here isn’t sentimental tolerance; it’s social infrastructure. In pluralistic democracies, religion can be both identity and fault line. Koehler’s phrasing - “also part of freedom” - is a rhetorical compromise, an attempt to fold restraint into liberty rather than pitch them as enemies.
The line’s political utility is obvious: it speaks to majority anxieties about cohesion while signaling to religious minorities that belonging isn’t conditional on invisibility. At the same time, it carries a risk: “respect” can become a soft tool for policing dissent. Koehler is betting that democratic culture survives not just on rights, but on the everyday choice not to weaponize them.
The intent is defensive as much as aspirational. As a German statesman speaking in a post-9/11, post-cartoon-controversy climate, Koehler is implicitly addressing the recurring question: does free expression include the right to offend? He doesn’t deny the right, but he shifts the frame from legal entitlement to civic consequence. That’s the subtext: a society can protect speech and still expect citizens not to treat provocation as a virtue.
It also quietly redefines freedom as relational rather than purely individual. Respect here isn’t sentimental tolerance; it’s social infrastructure. In pluralistic democracies, religion can be both identity and fault line. Koehler’s phrasing - “also part of freedom” - is a rhetorical compromise, an attempt to fold restraint into liberty rather than pitch them as enemies.
The line’s political utility is obvious: it speaks to majority anxieties about cohesion while signaling to religious minorities that belonging isn’t conditional on invisibility. At the same time, it carries a risk: “respect” can become a soft tool for policing dissent. Koehler is betting that democratic culture survives not just on rights, but on the everyday choice not to weaponize them.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Horst
Add to List








