"Roger Maris was as good a man and as good a ballplayer as there ever was"
About this Quote
Mantle isn’t just praising a teammate; he’s repairing a cultural bruise. When he calls Roger Maris “as good a man and as good a ballplayer as there ever was,” the line works because it collapses two scoreboards into one: character and performance. That pairing matters. Maris didn’t merely chase a record in 1961; he did it while being treated like an interloper in his own clubhouse myth, booed in Yankee Stadium, scrutinized by a press corps that wanted Babe Ruth’s legend preserved and Mantle’s charisma centered. “As good a man” is Mantle’s way of saying: we failed him, publicly.
The phrasing is deliberately plain, almost blunt, which is precisely why it lands. Mantle was the larger icon and, for much of that season, the preferred hero. A more self-protective version of history would frame Maris as a beneficiary of circumstances, the guy who stayed healthy, the guy who finished the job after Mantle faded. Instead, Mantle offers a totalizing endorsement: “as there ever was.” It’s a maximal statement from someone who could afford to be minimal.
The subtext is guilt and respect braided together. Mantle knew what it meant to be loved by default; Maris learned what it meant to be doubted by tradition. Coming from an athlete whose own legend often runs on excess, this modest sentence reads like an attempt at moral balance: a star using his authority to grant Maris what the era withheld - uncomplicated legitimacy.
The phrasing is deliberately plain, almost blunt, which is precisely why it lands. Mantle was the larger icon and, for much of that season, the preferred hero. A more self-protective version of history would frame Maris as a beneficiary of circumstances, the guy who stayed healthy, the guy who finished the job after Mantle faded. Instead, Mantle offers a totalizing endorsement: “as there ever was.” It’s a maximal statement from someone who could afford to be minimal.
The subtext is guilt and respect braided together. Mantle knew what it meant to be loved by default; Maris learned what it meant to be doubted by tradition. Coming from an athlete whose own legend often runs on excess, this modest sentence reads like an attempt at moral balance: a star using his authority to grant Maris what the era withheld - uncomplicated legitimacy.
Quote Details
| Topic | Legacy & Remembrance |
|---|---|
| Source | Murray Chass, "Roger Maris, 51, Is Dead; Was Longtime Yankee Outfielder," New York Times, Dec 15, 1985 — obituary reports Mickey Mantle praising Maris (Mantle called him as good a man and as good a ballplayer as there ever was). |
More Quotes by Mickey
Add to List


