"Rooting is following, and I don't do that, but I'd like to see the Phillies win because I love Philadelphia"
About this Quote
Carlton threads a needle that every superstar athlete eventually faces: how to claim loyalty without surrendering autonomy. “Rooting is following” is a deliberately prickly definition, turning a harmless civic pastime into a kind of herd behavior. It’s also a self-portrait. Carlton, the famously intense ace, built a brand on being unbothered by expectations, reporters, even teammates. In that light, refusing to “root” isn’t anti-Philadelphia; it’s anti-obligation.
The second half flips the temperature. “But I’d like to see the Phillies win” softens the edge just enough to keep the relationship intact, then “because I love Philadelphia” lands as a pure, uncomplicated vow. The subtext is that his allegiance is emotional, not performative. He won’t do fandom the way fans do it - he won’t wear the costume, chant on cue, or join the crowd’s mood swings - but he reserves the right to feel something real for the city that framed his legend.
Context matters: in Philadelphia, sports devotion isn’t background noise; it’s civic identity, a loyalty test administered nightly. Carlton’s line respects that intensity while asserting a star’s distance from it. He’s telling the city: I’m not one of you, but I’m with you. It’s a negotiation between icon and audience, and it works because it doesn’t pander. It’s affection with boundaries, the kind that feels more believable precisely because it’s slightly reluctant.
The second half flips the temperature. “But I’d like to see the Phillies win” softens the edge just enough to keep the relationship intact, then “because I love Philadelphia” lands as a pure, uncomplicated vow. The subtext is that his allegiance is emotional, not performative. He won’t do fandom the way fans do it - he won’t wear the costume, chant on cue, or join the crowd’s mood swings - but he reserves the right to feel something real for the city that framed his legend.
Context matters: in Philadelphia, sports devotion isn’t background noise; it’s civic identity, a loyalty test administered nightly. Carlton’s line respects that intensity while asserting a star’s distance from it. He’s telling the city: I’m not one of you, but I’m with you. It’s a negotiation between icon and audience, and it works because it doesn’t pander. It’s affection with boundaries, the kind that feels more believable precisely because it’s slightly reluctant.
Quote Details
| Topic | Sports |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Steve
Add to List





