"Say what you like about my bloody murderous government,' I says, 'but don't insult me poor bleedin' country"
About this Quote
Leave it to Edward Abbey to bottle the whole American neurosis in one foul-mouthed line: the ability to despise the state while clutching the nation to your chest like a wounded pet. The speaker’s pub-brawl diction ("I says", "bleedin'") isn’t just comic color; it’s a deliberate lowering of the register that makes patriotism sound less like a sermon and more like a reflex. Abbey turns political critique into a barroom boundary dispute: you can curse the government all day, but the moment you "insult" the country, you’ve crossed from dissent into heresy.
The intent is double-edged. On the surface, it’s a defense of ordinary people against elites who confuse government with nation. Abbey, suspicious of bureaucracies and war-making machines, grants you permission to call the regime "bloody murderous" - an accusation that lands harder because it’s framed as casual, obvious truth. The subtext, though, is darker: nationalism survives by outsourcing guilt. If the government is the monster, the country remains innocent, even when the monster is acting in its name and funded by its citizens. Abbey knows that contradiction is the point; the line thrives on the psychological need to keep loving the idea of home while acknowledging the violence done under its flag.
Context matters: Abbey wrote from the long shadow of Vietnam and the Cold War, when "support the troops" rhetoric could coexist with deep cynicism about Washington. The quote exposes that compartmentalization and mocks it, even as it admits how stubbornly human it is.
The intent is double-edged. On the surface, it’s a defense of ordinary people against elites who confuse government with nation. Abbey, suspicious of bureaucracies and war-making machines, grants you permission to call the regime "bloody murderous" - an accusation that lands harder because it’s framed as casual, obvious truth. The subtext, though, is darker: nationalism survives by outsourcing guilt. If the government is the monster, the country remains innocent, even when the monster is acting in its name and funded by its citizens. Abbey knows that contradiction is the point; the line thrives on the psychological need to keep loving the idea of home while acknowledging the violence done under its flag.
Context matters: Abbey wrote from the long shadow of Vietnam and the Cold War, when "support the troops" rhetoric could coexist with deep cynicism about Washington. The quote exposes that compartmentalization and mocks it, even as it admits how stubbornly human it is.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Edward
Add to List
