"Scarce any problem will appear more hard and difficult, than that of determining the distance of the Sun from the Earth very near the truth: but even this... will without much labour be effected"
About this Quote
Confidence, in Halley's hands, is a kind of instrument. He opens by conceding the obvious: measuring the Sun-Earth distance is brutally hard, a problem so foundational it borders on philosophical. Then comes the pivot - "but even this... will without much labour be effected" - a slyly radical claim in an era when astronomy still had one foot in guesswork and one in theology. Halley isn't just forecasting a technical win; he's staging a cultural flex for the new science: nature looks intimidating until you ask the right question in the right way.
The subtext is institutional. Halley knows he likely won't live to see the result. His famous proposal to use transits of Venus as a yardstick depends on global coordination, patient timing, and shared standards of observation. "Without much labour" doesn't mean effortless; it means modular. The hard part is not heroic genius but logistics: multiple observers, disciplined measurement, a method that turns scattered eyewitnessing into a single number. He's advertising a new kind of authority, where truth is manufactured by networks and procedures rather than proclamations.
Context matters: the Newtonian revolution has made the solar system mathematically legible, but the actual scale remains fuzzy. Halley is naming the missing piece, then reassuring his peers that it can be pinned down. It's rhetoric designed to recruit: a call to treat precision as attainable, and to treat collaboration as the engine of discovery.
The subtext is institutional. Halley knows he likely won't live to see the result. His famous proposal to use transits of Venus as a yardstick depends on global coordination, patient timing, and shared standards of observation. "Without much labour" doesn't mean effortless; it means modular. The hard part is not heroic genius but logistics: multiple observers, disciplined measurement, a method that turns scattered eyewitnessing into a single number. He's advertising a new kind of authority, where truth is manufactured by networks and procedures rather than proclamations.
Context matters: the Newtonian revolution has made the solar system mathematically legible, but the actual scale remains fuzzy. Halley is naming the missing piece, then reassuring his peers that it can be pinned down. It's rhetoric designed to recruit: a call to treat precision as attainable, and to treat collaboration as the engine of discovery.
Quote Details
| Topic | Science |
|---|
More Quotes by Edmond
Add to List









