"Scholarship except by accident is never the measure of a person's power"
About this Quote
Holland’s line needles a comforting Victorian faith: that learning naturally produces authority. He’s not anti-intellectual so much as anti-credential, aiming at the soft delusion that erudition is a moral solvent that dissolves real-world limits. “Except by accident” is the knife twist. It suggests scholarship can coincide with power, but only as a lucky alignment of circumstances - patronage, class position, timing, the right institution - not as a reliable engine. The sentence refuses the meritocratic bedtime story.
The subtext is a shrewd reading of how power actually behaves: it’s social, performative, networked. Scholarship is inward-facing; power is outward-facing. One accumulates knowledge, the other organizes people, resources, and fear. Holland, writing in an America where higher education was expanding but still gatekept, is basically warning readers not to confuse mental furniture for leverage. You can know everything and still be ignorable.
As a novelist, Holland also understands narrative authority: who gets listened to is rarely the most informed person in the room. Power rewards fluency, charisma, and the ability to set terms - to define what counts as “common sense” - more than it rewards correctness. That’s why the quote still lands: it calls out a modern habit of treating expertise as a force field. Sometimes it is; often it’s just a library card in a world run by landlords, bosses, party machines, and whoever controls the microphone.
The subtext is a shrewd reading of how power actually behaves: it’s social, performative, networked. Scholarship is inward-facing; power is outward-facing. One accumulates knowledge, the other organizes people, resources, and fear. Holland, writing in an America where higher education was expanding but still gatekept, is basically warning readers not to confuse mental furniture for leverage. You can know everything and still be ignorable.
As a novelist, Holland also understands narrative authority: who gets listened to is rarely the most informed person in the room. Power rewards fluency, charisma, and the ability to set terms - to define what counts as “common sense” - more than it rewards correctness. That’s why the quote still lands: it calls out a modern habit of treating expertise as a force field. Sometimes it is; often it’s just a library card in a world run by landlords, bosses, party machines, and whoever controls the microphone.
Quote Details
| Topic | Knowledge |
|---|
More Quotes by G. Holland
Add to List










