"Scientific prayer makes God a celestial lab rat, leading to bad science and worse religion"
About this Quote
Shermer’s line lands like a scalpel because it skewers two modern cravings at once: the hunger for certainty and the urge to outsource wonder to a measurable outcome. “Scientific prayer” isn’t just a quirky mashup; it’s a critique of the contemporary habit of treating faith like a consumer product with a warranty. Pray, run the trial, check the results. If it “works,” God is real; if not, God fails quality control.
The phrase “celestial lab rat” is doing the heavy lifting. It flips the power dynamic: the believer becomes the experimenter, God becomes the subject, and the sacred gets reduced to a testable mechanism. That inversion is the point. Shermer is less interested in mocking prayer than in mocking the instrumentalization of it - prayer as a technique for getting stuff, rather than a practice of meaning, surrender, or community.
His jab at “bad science” highlights a category error. Prayer studies often struggle with messy variables (who prays, how, for what, with what beliefs) and with outcomes that can’t be cleanly defined without smuggling in theology. The “worse religion” is the deeper indictment: if you treat God as something to be experimentally verified on demand, you end up with a brittle, transactional faith that collapses under the first null result.
Context matters: Shermer, as a prominent skeptic, is arguing against the false peace treaty between science and a certain kind of supernatural claim - not because he wants less spirituality, but because he wants clearer boundaries about what science can adjudicate and what religion becomes when it begs to be put on a spreadsheet.
The phrase “celestial lab rat” is doing the heavy lifting. It flips the power dynamic: the believer becomes the experimenter, God becomes the subject, and the sacred gets reduced to a testable mechanism. That inversion is the point. Shermer is less interested in mocking prayer than in mocking the instrumentalization of it - prayer as a technique for getting stuff, rather than a practice of meaning, surrender, or community.
His jab at “bad science” highlights a category error. Prayer studies often struggle with messy variables (who prays, how, for what, with what beliefs) and with outcomes that can’t be cleanly defined without smuggling in theology. The “worse religion” is the deeper indictment: if you treat God as something to be experimentally verified on demand, you end up with a brittle, transactional faith that collapses under the first null result.
Context matters: Shermer, as a prominent skeptic, is arguing against the false peace treaty between science and a certain kind of supernatural claim - not because he wants less spirituality, but because he wants clearer boundaries about what science can adjudicate and what religion becomes when it begs to be put on a spreadsheet.
Quote Details
| Topic | Prayer |
|---|
More Quotes by Michael
Add to List
