"Second to agriculture, humbug is the biggest industry of our age"
About this Quote
Nobel’s line lands like a dry detonation: from the man who literally industrialized explosives comes a complaint about an industry even more pervasive than gunpowder. Calling “humbug” the biggest business after agriculture isn’t just cranky disdain for fakery; it’s a diagnosis of modernity. Agriculture feeds bodies. Humbug feeds attention, status, and the comforting stories people buy when reality is messy, technical, or morally inconvenient.
The bite is in the word choice. “Industry” is doing double duty: it nods to factories, patents, and the new machinery of mass production, while also implying a system with supply chains and profit incentives. Humbug isn’t an occasional con; it’s organized, scalable, and, crucially, in demand. Nobel’s subtext is that deception thrives not because there are liars, but because there are markets for being lied to: political slogans that simplify, miracle cures that promise control, financial schemes that repackage risk as destiny.
Context sharpens the cynicism. Nobel lived in the late 19th century, when science was remaking daily life and public life was learning to sell itself through newspapers, advertising, and spectacle. The same era that minted new knowledge also minted new forms of persuasion, where truth competed with whatever was easiest to print, pitch, or rally around. Coming from a scientist, the line carries a professional grievance: facts are hard-won, but nonsense can be manufactured cheaply and distributed efficiently.
It’s also self-implicating. Nobel knew reputations can be engineered, industries can launder their harm, and progress can be marketed as virtue. Humbug, he suggests, is not the opposite of modern progress; it’s one of its most reliable byproducts.
The bite is in the word choice. “Industry” is doing double duty: it nods to factories, patents, and the new machinery of mass production, while also implying a system with supply chains and profit incentives. Humbug isn’t an occasional con; it’s organized, scalable, and, crucially, in demand. Nobel’s subtext is that deception thrives not because there are liars, but because there are markets for being lied to: political slogans that simplify, miracle cures that promise control, financial schemes that repackage risk as destiny.
Context sharpens the cynicism. Nobel lived in the late 19th century, when science was remaking daily life and public life was learning to sell itself through newspapers, advertising, and spectacle. The same era that minted new knowledge also minted new forms of persuasion, where truth competed with whatever was easiest to print, pitch, or rally around. Coming from a scientist, the line carries a professional grievance: facts are hard-won, but nonsense can be manufactured cheaply and distributed efficiently.
It’s also self-implicating. Nobel knew reputations can be engineered, industries can launder their harm, and progress can be marketed as virtue. Humbug, he suggests, is not the opposite of modern progress; it’s one of its most reliable byproducts.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Alfred
Add to List
