"Selfishness is the only real atheism; unselfishness the only real religion"
About this Quote
Zangwill’s line is a sly act of semantic jujitsu: he strips “religion” and “atheism” of their creeds and reassigns them to behavior. The provocation isn’t really about whether God exists; it’s about what you worship when nobody’s watching. In his framing, selfishness functions like atheism because it denies any claim larger than the self any binding authority. Unselfishness, by contrast, becomes “religion” because it performs the one thing religions constantly demand in theory and often fail to secure in practice: sacrifice, obligation, care.
The intent is also defensive, even strategic. Zangwill, a prominent Anglo-Jewish writer with deep ties to Jewish communal politics and Zionism, lived in an era when religious identity was both a moral credential and a social suspicion. Recasting religion as ethics rather than doctrine lets him praise the devout and the secular on the same scale, while quietly indicting pious hypocrisy. The subtext is: stop arguing metaphysics to excuse bad behavior; your moral seriousness is legible in your appetites.
Calling selfishness “the only real atheism” is pointedly unfair to actual atheists, and that’s part of the wit. He weaponizes the era’s anxiety about godlessness to target a more socially acceptable vice: acquisitiveness, status, the complacent ego of the respectable classes. It’s a moral gut-punch disguised as a definition, the kind that lands because it sounds like it’s merely clarifying terms while actually rewriting the scoreboard.
The intent is also defensive, even strategic. Zangwill, a prominent Anglo-Jewish writer with deep ties to Jewish communal politics and Zionism, lived in an era when religious identity was both a moral credential and a social suspicion. Recasting religion as ethics rather than doctrine lets him praise the devout and the secular on the same scale, while quietly indicting pious hypocrisy. The subtext is: stop arguing metaphysics to excuse bad behavior; your moral seriousness is legible in your appetites.
Calling selfishness “the only real atheism” is pointedly unfair to actual atheists, and that’s part of the wit. He weaponizes the era’s anxiety about godlessness to target a more socially acceptable vice: acquisitiveness, status, the complacent ego of the respectable classes. It’s a moral gut-punch disguised as a definition, the kind that lands because it sounds like it’s merely clarifying terms while actually rewriting the scoreboard.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Israel
Add to List







