"Sex is not sinful, but sin has perverted it"
About this Quote
A director’s line like this is doing two jobs at once: laundering desire through moral language, then turning that moral language back into a critique. “Sex is not sinful” opens the door with a plainspoken concession, the kind that sounds brave in eras when studios still policed bodies and censors treated bedrooms like crime scenes. But the second clause snaps the latch: “sin has perverted it.” The sentence isn’t a celebration of liberation so much as a bid to control the terms of liberation.
The cleverness is in the grammatical pivot. Sex is framed as neutral, even natural; the problem gets outsourced to “sin,” an abstract villain that can mean almost anything the speaker needs it to mean: exploitation, secrecy, coercion, obsession, hypocrisy, commerce. That vagueness is the point. It lets the quote sound permissive while keeping a moral perimeter intact. You can approve of sex, so long as you disapprove of the messy parts people actually argue about.
Coming from a director, it also reads as a backstage defense of representation. Film has always been accused of corrupting audiences; this line flips the charge. The camera isn’t the corrupter. Human vice is. It’s an argument for depicting sex without endorsing moral collapse, a way to claim seriousness over titillation. Subtext: don’t blame the act, blame the motives and the systems around it. That’s a surprisingly modern dodge - and a very old strategy for making the controversial sound responsible.
The cleverness is in the grammatical pivot. Sex is framed as neutral, even natural; the problem gets outsourced to “sin,” an abstract villain that can mean almost anything the speaker needs it to mean: exploitation, secrecy, coercion, obsession, hypocrisy, commerce. That vagueness is the point. It lets the quote sound permissive while keeping a moral perimeter intact. You can approve of sex, so long as you disapprove of the messy parts people actually argue about.
Coming from a director, it also reads as a backstage defense of representation. Film has always been accused of corrupting audiences; this line flips the charge. The camera isn’t the corrupter. Human vice is. It’s an argument for depicting sex without endorsing moral collapse, a way to claim seriousness over titillation. Subtext: don’t blame the act, blame the motives and the systems around it. That’s a surprisingly modern dodge - and a very old strategy for making the controversial sound responsible.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Walter
Add to List





