"Sharing is sometimes more demanding than giving"
About this Quote
“Sharing” sounds like the kinder, softer cousin of “giving,” but Bateson flips the hierarchy: sharing can cost more because it refuses the clean exit. Giving often preserves control. You choose the object, the timing, the terms, and you can walk away with your virtue neatly packaged. Sharing is messier. It asks for ongoing negotiation, mutual dependence, and the willingness to let what’s “yours” be reshaped by someone else’s needs.
As a scientist and cultural thinker attuned to systems, Bateson is pushing against the individualist fantasy that generosity is a one-way transfer. Sharing implies a commons: a space where boundaries are porous and outcomes aren’t fully predictable. That unpredictability is the demand. It requires attention, patience, and a tolerance for friction. Share a home, a project, a caregiving role, a lab, even a conversation, and you’re signing up for coordination costs: compromised preferences, repeated small adjustments, the emotional labor of staying in relation.
The subtext is a critique of performative altruism. “Giving” can be a moral gesture that leaves hierarchies intact: benefactor and beneficiary. Sharing threatens that asymmetry because it places both parties inside the same weather system. It’s intimate, and intimacy is expensive.
Context matters: Bateson wrote and spoke across decades when social life was being reorganized by mobility, professionalization, and later, networked digital culture. In an era obsessed with donations, “likes,” and one-off interventions, her line is a quiet rebuke: the harder work isn’t the grand gift; it’s sustained cohabitation with other people’s realities.
As a scientist and cultural thinker attuned to systems, Bateson is pushing against the individualist fantasy that generosity is a one-way transfer. Sharing implies a commons: a space where boundaries are porous and outcomes aren’t fully predictable. That unpredictability is the demand. It requires attention, patience, and a tolerance for friction. Share a home, a project, a caregiving role, a lab, even a conversation, and you’re signing up for coordination costs: compromised preferences, repeated small adjustments, the emotional labor of staying in relation.
The subtext is a critique of performative altruism. “Giving” can be a moral gesture that leaves hierarchies intact: benefactor and beneficiary. Sharing threatens that asymmetry because it places both parties inside the same weather system. It’s intimate, and intimacy is expensive.
Context matters: Bateson wrote and spoke across decades when social life was being reorganized by mobility, professionalization, and later, networked digital culture. In an era obsessed with donations, “likes,” and one-off interventions, her line is a quiet rebuke: the harder work isn’t the grand gift; it’s sustained cohabitation with other people’s realities.
Quote Details
| Topic | Kindness |
|---|
More Quotes by Mary
Add to List











