"Sin has many tools, but a lie is the handle which fits them all"
About this Quote
Burke frames sin less as a burst of passion than as a piece of engineering: it needs leverage. Calling the lie a "handle" is brutally practical. Handles are what make heavy, awkward things portable; they let you swing an object with force and control. In Burke's moral physics, wrongdoing isn’t chiefly powered by appetite but by narrative. The lie is the grip that lets every other vice be carried into public life, dressed up as necessity, principle, patriotism.
The line also smuggles in a political warning. As an 18th-century statesman watching empires strain and revolutions advertise themselves as virtue, Burke understood that large-scale harm rarely arrives announcing itself as harm. It arrives with a story that makes it feel coherent: that violence is purification, that corruption is stability, that expedience is wisdom. Sin’s "many tools" are the familiar arsenal - greed, cruelty, ambition - but the lie is what standardizes them, turning scattered impulses into a usable system.
Burke’s intent is to collapse the distance between private morality and public policy. A lie isn’t just a personal failing; it’s infrastructure. Once a society treats dishonesty as a legitimate instrument, every tool can be lifted: laws can be bent, enemies invented, conscience anesthetized. The subtext is bleak and bracing: you don’t defeat wrongdoing by arguing about each ugly act in isolation. You go for the handle. You make lying too costly to hold.
The line also smuggles in a political warning. As an 18th-century statesman watching empires strain and revolutions advertise themselves as virtue, Burke understood that large-scale harm rarely arrives announcing itself as harm. It arrives with a story that makes it feel coherent: that violence is purification, that corruption is stability, that expedience is wisdom. Sin’s "many tools" are the familiar arsenal - greed, cruelty, ambition - but the lie is what standardizes them, turning scattered impulses into a usable system.
Burke’s intent is to collapse the distance between private morality and public policy. A lie isn’t just a personal failing; it’s infrastructure. Once a society treats dishonesty as a legitimate instrument, every tool can be lifted: laws can be bent, enemies invented, conscience anesthetized. The subtext is bleak and bracing: you don’t defeat wrongdoing by arguing about each ugly act in isolation. You go for the handle. You make lying too costly to hold.
Quote Details
| Topic | Honesty & Integrity |
|---|
More Quotes by Edmund
Add to List
