"Since a politician never believes what he says, he is quite surprised to be taken at his word"
About this Quote
Cynicism lands harder when it comes from someone who actually governed, and de Gaulle’s line has the cold efficiency of battlefield humor. It’s not just a jab at political lying; it’s a diagnosis of a system where language is treated as a tool, not a bond. The politician, in this view, doesn’t “say” things to reveal conviction but to manage forces: placate factions, test public appetite, box in rivals, buy time. Truth becomes less a standard than a negotiable resource.
The sting is in the second half: “quite surprised to be taken at his word.” De Gaulle isn’t only accusing politicians of bad faith; he’s accusing the public, the press, and opponents of naivete when they pretend political speech is a literal contract. The subtext is almost Machiavellian: you should know the game you’re watching. If you insist on treating rhetoric as confession, you’ll misunderstand power - and you’ll be played by it.
Context matters. De Gaulle emerged from moments when national survival demanded strategic ambiguity: wartime resistance, the collapse of the Fourth Republic, the Algerian crisis, the invention of a stronger presidency. He relied on grand language and deliberate vagueness to hold together incompatible constituencies. That lived experience turns the quote into something more than a moral complaint. It’s a warning about modern governance: in high-stakes politics, sincerity is often a liability, and the real shock is when anyone expects otherwise.
The sting is in the second half: “quite surprised to be taken at his word.” De Gaulle isn’t only accusing politicians of bad faith; he’s accusing the public, the press, and opponents of naivete when they pretend political speech is a literal contract. The subtext is almost Machiavellian: you should know the game you’re watching. If you insist on treating rhetoric as confession, you’ll misunderstand power - and you’ll be played by it.
Context matters. De Gaulle emerged from moments when national survival demanded strategic ambiguity: wartime resistance, the collapse of the Fourth Republic, the Algerian crisis, the invention of a stronger presidency. He relied on grand language and deliberate vagueness to hold together incompatible constituencies. That lived experience turns the quote into something more than a moral complaint. It’s a warning about modern governance: in high-stakes politics, sincerity is often a liability, and the real shock is when anyone expects otherwise.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Charles
Add to List
