"Since every man desires happiness, it is evidently no small matter whether he conceives of happiness in terms of work or of enjoyment"
About this Quote
Babbitt slips a moral landmine under the word "happiness". He treats it less as a feeling than as a working definition that quietly governs an entire life. If everyone wants happiness, he implies, the real fight is over the blueprint: do you imagine happiness as something earned through disciplined effort, or as something consumed through pleasure? That distinction sounds private, even philosophical, until you realize Babbitt is really talking about civic character. A culture that teaches happiness-as-enjoyment will mint citizens trained to demand; a culture that frames happiness-as-work will produce people trained to endure, to build, to restrain themselves.
The line’s power comes from its calm, almost bureaucratic phrasing. "Evidently" and "no small matter" perform understatement, masking a fairly severe judgment. Babbitt, a leading voice in early 20th-century "New Humanism", was pushing back against what he saw as modernity’s drift: consumer appetite, therapeutic self-justification, and the loosening of inherited moral limits. Read in that context, "work" isn’t just labor; it’s the discipline of the will, the practice of self-command. "Enjoyment" isn’t innocent fun; it’s the ideology of gratification.
The subtext is a warning about definitions becoming destiny. If happiness is enjoyment, then obstacles look like injustices. If happiness is work, obstacles look like training. Babbitt isn’t denying pleasure; he’s arguing that a society survives on the stories it tells about what a good life is for.
The line’s power comes from its calm, almost bureaucratic phrasing. "Evidently" and "no small matter" perform understatement, masking a fairly severe judgment. Babbitt, a leading voice in early 20th-century "New Humanism", was pushing back against what he saw as modernity’s drift: consumer appetite, therapeutic self-justification, and the loosening of inherited moral limits. Read in that context, "work" isn’t just labor; it’s the discipline of the will, the practice of self-command. "Enjoyment" isn’t innocent fun; it’s the ideology of gratification.
The subtext is a warning about definitions becoming destiny. If happiness is enjoyment, then obstacles look like injustices. If happiness is work, obstacles look like training. Babbitt isn’t denying pleasure; he’s arguing that a society survives on the stories it tells about what a good life is for.
Quote Details
| Topic | Happiness |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Irving
Add to List








