"Since September 11th, federal terrorism investigations have resulted in charges against more than 400 suspects, and more than half of them have been convicted"
About this Quote
The numbers are doing the heavy lifting here, and that is the point. Sensenbrenner isn’t offering a neutral update; he’s staging a justification. Post-9/11 counterterror policy was sold on urgency and exceptional measures, and a clean statistic like “more than 400” suspects functions as proof-of-work: we acted, we found people, we prosecuted them. The follow-up clause, “more than half…convicted,” is crafted to signal competence and legitimacy at once, implying these investigations weren’t mere fishing expeditions.
But the subtext is where the quote tightens. “Charged” is not “guilty,” and “more than half” quietly concedes that a substantial share were not convicted. That gap disappears under the momentum of the big number, which is a classic law-and-order rhetorical move: emphasize throughput, not precision. It also invites listeners to equate terrorism investigations with terrorism itself, when many post-9/11 cases involved peripheral conduct (material support, immigration violations, informant-driven stings) that expand the net while muddying what “terrorism” means in practice.
Context matters because Sensenbrenner, as a security-forward Republican and former House Judiciary chair, operated in a political economy where fear demanded visible enforcement. The quote is calibrated for oversight hearings and cable-news digestion: an argument for broad authorities, robust funding, and deference to federal agencies, with statistical reassurance standing in for the harder questions about civil liberties, entrapment, and whether conviction rates measure safety or simply prosecutorial leverage.
But the subtext is where the quote tightens. “Charged” is not “guilty,” and “more than half” quietly concedes that a substantial share were not convicted. That gap disappears under the momentum of the big number, which is a classic law-and-order rhetorical move: emphasize throughput, not precision. It also invites listeners to equate terrorism investigations with terrorism itself, when many post-9/11 cases involved peripheral conduct (material support, immigration violations, informant-driven stings) that expand the net while muddying what “terrorism” means in practice.
Context matters because Sensenbrenner, as a security-forward Republican and former House Judiciary chair, operated in a political economy where fear demanded visible enforcement. The quote is calibrated for oversight hearings and cable-news digestion: an argument for broad authorities, robust funding, and deference to federal agencies, with statistical reassurance standing in for the harder questions about civil liberties, entrapment, and whether conviction rates measure safety or simply prosecutorial leverage.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Jim
Add to List



