"Skepticism is an important historical tool. It is the starting point of all revision of hitherto accepted history"
About this Quote
Skepticism, in Morison's hands, isn't a vibe or a posture; it's a method with teeth. Coming from a historian who made his name writing confident, narrative-driven accounts of America (and who also served as an official chronicler of the Navy in World War II), the line reads less like anti-authoritarian swagger and more like a professional memo: if you don't doubt, you're not doing the job.
The phrasing is surgical. "Historical tool" frames skepticism as instrumentation, not ideology. It's something you pick up and use against sources, myths, even your own storytelling instincts. Then Morison tightens the screw with "starting point" and "revision". He doesn't romanticize the past as settled truth; he treats it as provisional, a draft that keeps getting edited as archives open, methods improve, and society asks different questions. "Hitherto accepted history" is the real target. Accepted by whom? Schools, governments, gatekeepers, comfortable majorities. The subtext is that consensus is often just convenience wearing a cap and gown.
Context matters: Morison wrote across decades when American history was being professionalized, nationalized, and mobilized for civic education and wartime morale. In that environment, skepticism is not mere contrarianism; it's a guardrail against propaganda and inherited bias. The sentence also carries an implicit warning to historians themselves: your narrative talent can seduce you into believing your own coherence. Skepticism is how the discipline keeps its conscience intact while still telling stories people will actually read.
The phrasing is surgical. "Historical tool" frames skepticism as instrumentation, not ideology. It's something you pick up and use against sources, myths, even your own storytelling instincts. Then Morison tightens the screw with "starting point" and "revision". He doesn't romanticize the past as settled truth; he treats it as provisional, a draft that keeps getting edited as archives open, methods improve, and society asks different questions. "Hitherto accepted history" is the real target. Accepted by whom? Schools, governments, gatekeepers, comfortable majorities. The subtext is that consensus is often just convenience wearing a cap and gown.
Context matters: Morison wrote across decades when American history was being professionalized, nationalized, and mobilized for civic education and wartime morale. In that environment, skepticism is not mere contrarianism; it's a guardrail against propaganda and inherited bias. The sentence also carries an implicit warning to historians themselves: your narrative talent can seduce you into believing your own coherence. Skepticism is how the discipline keeps its conscience intact while still telling stories people will actually read.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by Samuel
Add to List






