"So I think, if September 11 taught us anything, it taught us that we're vulnerable, and vulnerable in ways that we didn't fully understand"
About this Quote
A polished admission of fragility, delivered in the careful dialect of state power. Condoleezza Rice frames 9/11 as a national lesson, but the line’s real work is to convert shock into policy permission. “If September 11 taught us anything” sounds humble, almost seminar-room reflective, yet it quietly asserts that the proper response to catastrophe is pedagogical: learn, adapt, act. The passive construction (“taught us”) also softens agency. No one chose this curriculum, but everyone must now accept its conclusions.
The repetition of “vulnerable” does double duty. On one level, it punctures the pre-9/11 mythology of American invulnerability without sounding self-pitying. On another, it widens the aperture of threat: not just vulnerable, but “in ways that we didn’t fully understand.” That last clause is the hinge. It validates fear of the unseen and legitimizes extraordinary measures on the grounds that old maps no longer apply. If the danger is novel and illegible, then so can be the response.
Context matters: Rice, as a senior national security figure in the Bush administration, is speaking from inside the machinery that would soon rewire surveillance, detention, and military doctrine. The sentence is calibrated to feel like sober realism rather than a rhetorical bid. Its subtext isn’t simply “we were attacked”; it’s “the world has changed, uncertainty is the new baseline, and the state must expand its reach to manage it.” Vulnerability becomes both diagnosis and mandate.
The repetition of “vulnerable” does double duty. On one level, it punctures the pre-9/11 mythology of American invulnerability without sounding self-pitying. On another, it widens the aperture of threat: not just vulnerable, but “in ways that we didn’t fully understand.” That last clause is the hinge. It validates fear of the unseen and legitimizes extraordinary measures on the grounds that old maps no longer apply. If the danger is novel and illegible, then so can be the response.
Context matters: Rice, as a senior national security figure in the Bush administration, is speaking from inside the machinery that would soon rewire surveillance, detention, and military doctrine. The sentence is calibrated to feel like sober realism rather than a rhetorical bid. Its subtext isn’t simply “we were attacked”; it’s “the world has changed, uncertainty is the new baseline, and the state must expand its reach to manage it.” Vulnerability becomes both diagnosis and mandate.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by Condoleezza
Add to List
