"So what really works? Treatments in jail do some good, but it's mostly too late: finding a family and a job or just growing older make most prisoners eventually give up crime"
About this Quote
The sting here is the quiet inversion of what “tough on crime” rhetoric promises: the decisive turning points aren’t bars, lectures, or even the state’s rehabilitative programs, but ordinary life arriving late. Toynbee’s line pivots on that blunt “mostly too late,” a phrase that refuses the comforting fantasy that prison is a clean reset button. She grants jail treatment a grudging “some good,” then undercuts it with the suggestion that the system meets people only after the damage calcifies.
Her real argument is smuggled into the list that follows: “finding a family and a job or just growing older.” Those are not carceral tools; they’re forms of social attachment and time itself. The subtext is structural and slightly accusatory: we treat crime as an individual moral failure, then act surprised when the fixes that work are the ones that give people stakes in the world. “Family” and “job” aren’t sentimental here; they’re stabilizers, the everyday infrastructure of belonging that policy debates often treat as peripheral. Even “growing older” carries a dry, almost cynical punch: desistance can be less a triumph of correction than the slow cooling of impulse and opportunity.
As a journalist, Toynbee is also telegraphing a political context: Britain’s long oscillation between punitive slogans and underfunded rehabilitation. The sentence reads like a warning to policymakers chasing prison-based solutions: if the best predictors of quitting crime are social integration and maturity, then waiting until incarceration is not just expensive. It’s strategically backwards.
Her real argument is smuggled into the list that follows: “finding a family and a job or just growing older.” Those are not carceral tools; they’re forms of social attachment and time itself. The subtext is structural and slightly accusatory: we treat crime as an individual moral failure, then act surprised when the fixes that work are the ones that give people stakes in the world. “Family” and “job” aren’t sentimental here; they’re stabilizers, the everyday infrastructure of belonging that policy debates often treat as peripheral. Even “growing older” carries a dry, almost cynical punch: desistance can be less a triumph of correction than the slow cooling of impulse and opportunity.
As a journalist, Toynbee is also telegraphing a political context: Britain’s long oscillation between punitive slogans and underfunded rehabilitation. The sentence reads like a warning to policymakers chasing prison-based solutions: if the best predictors of quitting crime are social integration and maturity, then waiting until incarceration is not just expensive. It’s strategically backwards.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Polly
Add to List
