"Society is always taken by surprise at any new example of common sense"
About this Quote
Common sense, Emerson jabs, is less a shared civic resource than a disruptive technology. The line is funny because it flips the expected relationship: society congratulates itself on being practical, yet it reacts to actual practicality the way a stodgy institution reacts to a whistleblower - with shock, suspicion, and awkward applause after the fact. Emerson’s wit is surgical: “always” and “any” turn the indictment into a law of human behavior, not a one-off complaint. He’s not praising common sense as folksy wisdom; he’s exposing how rare it is when it threatens habit.
The subtext is a critique of social conformity dressed up as a compliment. “Society” here isn’t just government or the elite; it’s the consensus-making machine that smooths sharp edges, rewards imitation, and calls that stability “reason.” New common sense is “new” precisely because it refuses inherited scripts. It arrives looking like simplicity, but it functions like heresy: it makes the old, complicated rationalizations suddenly feel like what they are - elaborate defenses of inertia.
Context matters. Emerson’s Transcendentalist moment was steeped in distrust of institutions and in faith in the self’s moral perception. In essays like “Self-Reliance,” he argues that the crowd confuses familiarity with truth. This aphorism compresses that worldview into a social diagnosis: when someone states the obvious with clarity and spine, the culture treats it as revelation. The punchline is bleak: if common sense can still surprise us, we’ve built a society optimized not for thinking, but for agreement.
The subtext is a critique of social conformity dressed up as a compliment. “Society” here isn’t just government or the elite; it’s the consensus-making machine that smooths sharp edges, rewards imitation, and calls that stability “reason.” New common sense is “new” precisely because it refuses inherited scripts. It arrives looking like simplicity, but it functions like heresy: it makes the old, complicated rationalizations suddenly feel like what they are - elaborate defenses of inertia.
Context matters. Emerson’s Transcendentalist moment was steeped in distrust of institutions and in faith in the self’s moral perception. In essays like “Self-Reliance,” he argues that the crowd confuses familiarity with truth. This aphorism compresses that worldview into a social diagnosis: when someone states the obvious with clarity and spine, the culture treats it as revelation. The punchline is bleak: if common sense can still surprise us, we’ve built a society optimized not for thinking, but for agreement.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Ralph
Add to List









