"Some men are alive simply because it is against the law to kill them"
About this Quote
Howe lands the line like a judge delivering a verdict: withholding violence isn’t morality, it’s compliance. The sting is in the “simply.” It suggests certain people contribute so little - or do so much harm - that their continued existence isn’t owed to affection, respect, or even basic social regard, only to the thin legal barrier between civilization and impulse. It’s misanthropy, yes, but a deliberate kind: a way of shaming complacency by implying that decency can be embarrassingly low-effort.
The subtext is darker than a cheap laugh. Howe is pointing at the uncomfortable truth that law often substitutes for ethics. We like to imagine society held together by shared values; Howe implies it’s held together by penalties. That reframes “order” as an achievement of enforcement, not enlightenment. The line also carries a sly insult to the men in question: they’re not merely disliked, they’re the kind of disliked that makes people privately inventory which restraints keep them from acting on it.
Contextually, Howe wrote in a late 19th-century America where public morality, reform movements, and hard-edged journalism all wrestled with hypocrisy and corruption. His aphoristic style thrives on compression: one sentence that sounds like a joke until you realize it’s also a warning. Remove the law, and you don’t get freedom; you get a clearer picture of what some people have been barely choosing not to do.
The subtext is darker than a cheap laugh. Howe is pointing at the uncomfortable truth that law often substitutes for ethics. We like to imagine society held together by shared values; Howe implies it’s held together by penalties. That reframes “order” as an achievement of enforcement, not enlightenment. The line also carries a sly insult to the men in question: they’re not merely disliked, they’re the kind of disliked that makes people privately inventory which restraints keep them from acting on it.
Contextually, Howe wrote in a late 19th-century America where public morality, reform movements, and hard-edged journalism all wrestled with hypocrisy and corruption. His aphoristic style thrives on compression: one sentence that sounds like a joke until you realize it’s also a warning. Remove the law, and you don’t get freedom; you get a clearer picture of what some people have been barely choosing not to do.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Edward
Add to List
