"Some were brilliant bordering on genius. Others, genius bordering on madness"
About this Quote
As a novelist, Segal isn’t diagnosing anyone; he’s staging a social sorting mechanism. “Some were” and “Others” reads like a roll call, the voice of an observer (or institution) quietly assigning people into categories that flatter the first group and pathologize the second. The subtext: we celebrate exceptional minds when they’re legible, productive, charming - and we call the same intensity “madness” when it becomes inconvenient, disruptive, or simply too hard to translate into polite behavior.
What makes the line sting is its implication that the border is movable. Genius can be praised as brilliance when it serves the room, and condemned as instability when it refuses. Segal’s choice to place “madness” right up against “genius” doesn’t just flirt with the trope; it questions the audience’s appetite for it. We want gifted people to entertain us, solve problems, and stay aesthetically troubled rather than genuinely difficult. The quote exposes that bargain, and the quiet cruelty baked into it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Deep |
|---|---|
| Source | Evidence: Erich Segal. Prologue With a single exception they were all white . And with five exceptions all male . Some were brilliant bordering on genius . Others , genius bordering on madness . One had played a cello recital at Carnegie Hall ... Other candidates (1) Doctors (Erich Segal, 1988)50.0% Some were brilliant bordering on genius. Others, genius bordering on madness. (Prologue (page varies by edition; show... |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Segal, Erich. (2026, March 5). Some were brilliant bordering on genius. Others, genius bordering on madness. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/some-were-brilliant-bordering-on-genius-others-173438/
Chicago Style
Segal, Erich. "Some were brilliant bordering on genius. Others, genius bordering on madness." FixQuotes. March 5, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/some-were-brilliant-bordering-on-genius-others-173438/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"Some were brilliant bordering on genius. Others, genius bordering on madness." FixQuotes, 5 Mar. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/some-were-brilliant-bordering-on-genius-others-173438/. Accessed 27 Mar. 2026.








