"Somebody said they threw their copy of Dungeons and Dragons into the fire, and it screamed. It's a game! The magic spells in it are as real as the gold. Try retiring on that stuff"
About this Quote
Gygax takes a flamethrower to a familiar moral panic by laughing at it from the inside. The image is perfectly chosen: someone hurling a Dungeons and Dragons book into the fire like its a cursed object, then insisting it screamed. He doesnt rebut with piety; he escalates the absurdity until it collapses under its own weight. Thats the move of a designer defending an imagined world: he knows fantasy works because it feels vivid, and he refuses to apologize for that vividness.
The pivot line, "It's a game!", is less a clarification than a boundary. Gygax is drawing a hard line between play and belief at a moment when that line was being aggressively blurred. In the 1980s, D&D was dragged into the Satanic Panic, blamed for everything from teen rebellion to occult recruitment. By treating the accusation as a punchline, he deprives it of oxygen. Moral crusades rely on seriousness; comedy turns them into neighborhood gossip.
Then he lands the real argument in a single, almost cruel comparison: spells are "as real as the gold". He picks gold because its the most literal, least mystical measure of reality we have. If the treasure in the book cant pay your rent, neither can the sorcery. "Try retiring on that stuff" is practical Midwestern skepticism aimed at spiritual hysteria. Underneath the joke is a defense of imaginative culture: stories can change you, but they arent contraband artifacts. The point isnt that fantasy is harmless; its that the fear is lazy.
The pivot line, "It's a game!", is less a clarification than a boundary. Gygax is drawing a hard line between play and belief at a moment when that line was being aggressively blurred. In the 1980s, D&D was dragged into the Satanic Panic, blamed for everything from teen rebellion to occult recruitment. By treating the accusation as a punchline, he deprives it of oxygen. Moral crusades rely on seriousness; comedy turns them into neighborhood gossip.
Then he lands the real argument in a single, almost cruel comparison: spells are "as real as the gold". He picks gold because its the most literal, least mystical measure of reality we have. If the treasure in the book cant pay your rent, neither can the sorcery. "Try retiring on that stuff" is practical Midwestern skepticism aimed at spiritual hysteria. Underneath the joke is a defense of imaginative culture: stories can change you, but they arent contraband artifacts. The point isnt that fantasy is harmless; its that the fear is lazy.
Quote Details
| Topic | Sarcastic |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Gary
Add to List







