"Sometimes a scream is better than a thesis"
About this Quote
A laboratory is supposed to be the kingdom of the thesis: orderly arguments, numbered figures, a calm chain of inference. Eigen punctures that ideal with one brutal syllable: scream. Coming from a scientist famous for turning messy biological change into crisp mathematical models, the line lands as both confession and critique. It admits what the genre of scientific writing tries to launder away: discovery often begins as stress, bafflement, even panic - an emotional jolt when the data refuses to behave.
The intent isn’t anti-intellectual so much as anti-pretense. Eigen isn’t praising noise over knowledge; he’s pointing to the limits of polished explanation when you’re still inside the problem. A thesis is retrospective: it organizes the story after the fact, once uncertainty has been domesticated. A scream happens in real time. It marks contact with the unknown, the moment when comprehension hasn’t yet caught up to perception. That’s why it “can be better”: it’s honest about the gap.
There’s also a sly institutional subtext. Academia rewards composure and coherence; it penalizes raw alarm, doubt, and frustration - the very signals that something important might be happening. Eigen’s sentence gives permission to acknowledge the human body in the supposedly disembodied world of ideas. In a century that mythologized scientific rationality while also living through existential technological shocks, the line reads like a small act of resistance: don’t confuse the clean narrative of results with the jagged reality of thinking.
The intent isn’t anti-intellectual so much as anti-pretense. Eigen isn’t praising noise over knowledge; he’s pointing to the limits of polished explanation when you’re still inside the problem. A thesis is retrospective: it organizes the story after the fact, once uncertainty has been domesticated. A scream happens in real time. It marks contact with the unknown, the moment when comprehension hasn’t yet caught up to perception. That’s why it “can be better”: it’s honest about the gap.
There’s also a sly institutional subtext. Academia rewards composure and coherence; it penalizes raw alarm, doubt, and frustration - the very signals that something important might be happening. Eigen’s sentence gives permission to acknowledge the human body in the supposedly disembodied world of ideas. In a century that mythologized scientific rationality while also living through existential technological shocks, the line reads like a small act of resistance: don’t confuse the clean narrative of results with the jagged reality of thinking.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Manfred
Add to List
