"Sometimes dreams are wiser than waking"
About this Quote
In Black Elk's world, dreams arent escapist cinema; they are a parallel institution of knowledge, a serious civic channel. "Sometimes dreams are wiser than waking" lands with the authority of someone who watched the so-called waking world - treaties broken, land seized, a people forced to translate themselves under duress - and refused to pretend that daylight automatically equals truth.
The sentence pivots on "sometimes", a modest word that does heavy political work. It doesnt reject reality; it indicts a particular kind of reality-making: the colonial, bureaucratic "waking" that reduces life to paperwork, property lines, and measurable outcomes. Against that, Black Elk elevates the dream as a venue where relations - to ancestors, animals, place, the sacred - are not severed. Wisdom, here, isnt cleverness. Its alignment. A dream can be "wiser" because it remembers the moral map that waking society has agreed to forget.
The subtext is also tactical. When the public sphere is hostile, inner experience becomes a protected archive. To say dreams can outthink waking is to claim sovereignty over meaning itself, to insist that a people can be conquered territorially and still hold an intact epistemology.
Historically, this tracks with Black Elk's role as a holy man and visionary whose life spanned the violent transformation of the Plains. Read in that light, the line is both elegy and resistance: an argument that the most reliable intelligence may come not from the world as it is administered, but from the world as it is revealed.
The sentence pivots on "sometimes", a modest word that does heavy political work. It doesnt reject reality; it indicts a particular kind of reality-making: the colonial, bureaucratic "waking" that reduces life to paperwork, property lines, and measurable outcomes. Against that, Black Elk elevates the dream as a venue where relations - to ancestors, animals, place, the sacred - are not severed. Wisdom, here, isnt cleverness. Its alignment. A dream can be "wiser" because it remembers the moral map that waking society has agreed to forget.
The subtext is also tactical. When the public sphere is hostile, inner experience becomes a protected archive. To say dreams can outthink waking is to claim sovereignty over meaning itself, to insist that a people can be conquered territorially and still hold an intact epistemology.
Historically, this tracks with Black Elk's role as a holy man and visionary whose life spanned the violent transformation of the Plains. Read in that light, the line is both elegy and resistance: an argument that the most reliable intelligence may come not from the world as it is administered, but from the world as it is revealed.
Quote Details
| Topic | Native American Sayings |
|---|
More Quotes by Black
Add to List
