"Sometimes there's a snobbery among literary types that these people don't really get it, but in a lot of ways they get it more than the literati. There's a culture in the background that they understand and know. They get that deeper level"
About this Quote
The sting here is aimed less at “the public” than at the priesthood that claims to interpret it. Welsh is calling out a particular literary reflex: the assumption that cultural legitimacy runs uphill, from working life to educated commentary, and that the reader who hasn’t been credentialed can only skim the surface. Coming from a writer whose work is steeped in dialect, nightlife, addiction, and class friction, the critique lands as both aesthetic and political. He’s defending a readership that recognizes itself in the texture of the world on the page, even when gatekeepers reduce that texture to “grit” or “shock.”
The rhetoric turns on a neat reversal: the “literati” may possess critical vocabulary, but “these people” possess cultural fluency. Welsh isn’t romanticizing anti-intellectualism; he’s attacking a mismatch between what gets rewarded in literary culture (references, theory-ready themes, institutional approval) and what actually makes a novel feel true (social codes, humor, shame, status anxiety, the unspoken rules of a scene). “They get that deeper level” is the key provocation: depth isn’t synonymous with formal education. It can mean knowing exactly how a certain kind of bar talk works, why a gesture reads as disrespect, how class performs itself in a sentence.
In context, it’s also Welsh defending his own artistic method. His books often demand that readers meet the language and milieu where they are, not translate them into polite literary terms. The subtext is simple and sharp: if you can’t read the culture, you can’t claim to read the book.
The rhetoric turns on a neat reversal: the “literati” may possess critical vocabulary, but “these people” possess cultural fluency. Welsh isn’t romanticizing anti-intellectualism; he’s attacking a mismatch between what gets rewarded in literary culture (references, theory-ready themes, institutional approval) and what actually makes a novel feel true (social codes, humor, shame, status anxiety, the unspoken rules of a scene). “They get that deeper level” is the key provocation: depth isn’t synonymous with formal education. It can mean knowing exactly how a certain kind of bar talk works, why a gesture reads as disrespect, how class performs itself in a sentence.
In context, it’s also Welsh defending his own artistic method. His books often demand that readers meet the language and milieu where they are, not translate them into polite literary terms. The subtext is simple and sharp: if you can’t read the culture, you can’t claim to read the book.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Irvine
Add to List
