"South Dakota is a great state because of its values, not because of dependence on government"
About this Quote
“South Dakota is a great state because of its values” is doing two jobs at once: flattering a place and drawing a border around who gets to count as the “real” people in it. In Laura Ingraham’s hands, “values” isn’t a neutral compliment; it’s a political shorthand that bundles self-reliance, tradition, and suspicion of outsiders into a single warm word. The move is savvy because it invites agreement before you ever reach the argument. Who wants to be against values?
The second clause sharpens the blade: “not because of dependence on government.” That framing smuggles in a moral hierarchy. Government isn’t presented as a tool citizens use; it’s a temptation that turns neighbors into dependents. The subtext isn’t about South Dakota’s actual balance sheet or federal dollars so much as about identity: virtue is rural and local; vice is bureaucratic and distant. It’s a classic culture-war pivot: take a concrete subject (a state’s success) and recast it as a character test.
Context matters because “South Dakota” functions like a symbol more than a case study. In conservative media, red states are often cast as proof-of-concept for a whole worldview: freedom works, regulation corrupts, “real America” persists. Even if the empirical details complicate the story, the quote’s intent is emotional and tribal. It offers listeners a satisfying narrative where pride is earned, hardship is ennobling, and politics is a referendum on personal virtue rather than policy tradeoffs.
The second clause sharpens the blade: “not because of dependence on government.” That framing smuggles in a moral hierarchy. Government isn’t presented as a tool citizens use; it’s a temptation that turns neighbors into dependents. The subtext isn’t about South Dakota’s actual balance sheet or federal dollars so much as about identity: virtue is rural and local; vice is bureaucratic and distant. It’s a classic culture-war pivot: take a concrete subject (a state’s success) and recast it as a character test.
Context matters because “South Dakota” functions like a symbol more than a case study. In conservative media, red states are often cast as proof-of-concept for a whole worldview: freedom works, regulation corrupts, “real America” persists. Even if the empirical details complicate the story, the quote’s intent is emotional and tribal. It offers listeners a satisfying narrative where pride is earned, hardship is ennobling, and politics is a referendum on personal virtue rather than policy tradeoffs.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Laura
Add to List



