"Speech is human nature itself, with none of the artificiality of written language"
About this Quote
Whitehead’s line flatters the ear while quietly demoting the page. For a mathematician-philosopher who built systems out of symbols, calling speech “human nature itself” is less romantic than strategic: he’s staking a claim about what counts as primary experience. Speech is immediate, improvisational, full of hesitation and repair; it carries tone, timing, and the social pressure of having to be understood in real time. That messiness is the point. It’s how minds actually meet.
The jab at writing as “artificiality” isn’t anti-intellectual so much as anti-fetish. Written language looks stable, even inevitable. It edits out the false starts and the bodily cues, then pretends the cleaned-up product is what thought really was all along. Whitehead is warning that the clarity we admire in prose is partly manufactured by the medium itself. Writing doesn’t merely record meaning; it reorganizes it, standardizes it, and makes it portable for institutions - law, bureaucracy, academia - that depend on fixed texts.
Context matters: Whitehead’s career straddled the late Victorian faith in formalization and the early 20th-century crisis of certainty, when logic, mathematics, and philosophy were wrestling with whether symbols capture reality or just our preferred map of it. His subtext: don’t confuse the map for the terrain. In the age of print culture, and especially in disciplines that prize notation, he’s insisting that the “natural” human baseline is not the polished sentence but the living exchange - where meaning is negotiated, not archived.
The jab at writing as “artificiality” isn’t anti-intellectual so much as anti-fetish. Written language looks stable, even inevitable. It edits out the false starts and the bodily cues, then pretends the cleaned-up product is what thought really was all along. Whitehead is warning that the clarity we admire in prose is partly manufactured by the medium itself. Writing doesn’t merely record meaning; it reorganizes it, standardizes it, and makes it portable for institutions - law, bureaucracy, academia - that depend on fixed texts.
Context matters: Whitehead’s career straddled the late Victorian faith in formalization and the early 20th-century crisis of certainty, when logic, mathematics, and philosophy were wrestling with whether symbols capture reality or just our preferred map of it. His subtext: don’t confuse the map for the terrain. In the age of print culture, and especially in disciplines that prize notation, he’s insisting that the “natural” human baseline is not the polished sentence but the living exchange - where meaning is negotiated, not archived.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Alfred
Add to List





