"Spreading out the particle into a string is a step in the direction of making everything we're familiar with fuzzy. You enter a completely new world where things aren't at all what you're used to"
About this Quote
Witten sells string theory with a quiet provocation: it doesn’t just add a new ingredient to physics, it dissolves the texture of the old recipe. “Spreading out the particle into a string” is almost folksy as a phrase, but it’s doing hard rhetorical work. A “particle” is the emblem of classical certainty: a point you can locate, track, and treat as an object with clean edges. Replace that point with an extended “string” and you’ve already sabotaged the intuition that reality is built from tiny beads. The move is conceptual before it’s technical, and Witten foregrounds that.
“Fuzzy” is the tell. He’s not talking about vague thinking; he’s naming the kind of non-classical behavior that shows up when you push physics past its comfort zone: localization breaks down, interactions smear out, and the old habit of picturing a sharp event at a sharp place stops paying rent. In the background is a specific motivation: point particles create nasty infinities when you try to reconcile quantum mechanics with gravity. Strings, because they have extent, soften the collisions. The fuzziness is not an aesthetic choice; it’s a strategy for making the math stop exploding.
Then comes the persuasive pivot: “a completely new world.” It’s an invitation and a warning. Witten’s subtext is that resistance is inevitable because our mental models are parochial - evolved for mid-sized objects, not Planck-scale geometry. He’s also smuggling in a philosophy of progress: real advances in fundamental theory don’t feel like upgrades; they feel like losing the right to use familiar nouns.
“Fuzzy” is the tell. He’s not talking about vague thinking; he’s naming the kind of non-classical behavior that shows up when you push physics past its comfort zone: localization breaks down, interactions smear out, and the old habit of picturing a sharp event at a sharp place stops paying rent. In the background is a specific motivation: point particles create nasty infinities when you try to reconcile quantum mechanics with gravity. Strings, because they have extent, soften the collisions. The fuzziness is not an aesthetic choice; it’s a strategy for making the math stop exploding.
Then comes the persuasive pivot: “a completely new world.” It’s an invitation and a warning. Witten’s subtext is that resistance is inevitable because our mental models are parochial - evolved for mid-sized objects, not Planck-scale geometry. He’s also smuggling in a philosophy of progress: real advances in fundamental theory don’t feel like upgrades; they feel like losing the right to use familiar nouns.
Quote Details
| Topic | Science |
|---|
More Quotes by Edward
Add to List



